EXPLAINER

Why Russia hasn’t officially declared war

As Vladimir Putin steps back from his state of the nation speech, it's important to note that the Russian government has not formally declared war on Ukraine. But from a Ukrainian and western viewpoint, we can all see that a war is taking place. 

All governments in the Euro-Atlantic area (which includes the EU, UK, Canada and the US) describe the conflict in Ukraine as a war of aggression. In contrast, Russia has described its military actions as a “special military operation”. In his February 21 state of the nation address, Putin described the conflict as a defensive action to protect Russia and Russian speakers from Nato aggressors.


Why not declare war?

For the Russian government, positioning this as a defensive action in the state of the nation speech stops short of it being declared war. A full declaration of war would allow for greater conscription and divert more resources towards the military campaign. However, Russia has already invested heavily in the war, with its impact on the Russian economy and oligarch wealth and its connectivity with the wider world being restricted after many countries cut flights to Russian cities.

The Russian military frames “levels” of war, which describe the geography of a conflict and what sort of fighting is taking place. Former senior Russian policy figures have expanded these levels of war to include 17 rungs of escalation, and it is instructive to see where the conflict currently sits in both the levels and on the rungs.

The levels of war Russia uses are:

  • Armed conflict, which is limited and is between opposing sides within a single territory
  • A local war, which is the use of military tools to pursue military and political goals exclusively within the territory of the warring sides and where the interest being fought over is also between those sides
  • Regional war, which is a conflict including more than two states from the same region pursuing strategically important objectives
  • Large-scale war, which is war between coalitions of warring parties or world powers such as the US v Russia. In large-scale conflicts, there is a wide spread mobilization of the resources of the participating states, and can be an escalation from a smaller conflict.


On the 17-rung scale, hybrid warfare appears as rung four, including special forces, mercenaries, economic measures and information and psychological conflict. The annexation of Crimea by Russia in 2014 fitted this pattern. 

According to Russian logic, the invasion of Ukraine was intended to be a contained local war. The use of precision and conventional weapons would characterize it. According to this Russian way of war, regional war appears between the 7th and 11th rung and is typified by extensive conventional strikes. Regional war is judged to be the tipping point towards confrontation between great powers. 

So, the logic of the Russian position is to try and secure their political and military goals at the lowest level of war, with the least potential for escalation. While there have been concerns that the Ukrainian conflict might result in significant escalation to a major war or nuclear exchange, the Russian position appears to be aimed at keeping the conflict at the level of a local war. 

Formally declaring war on Ukraine would reduce Russia's ability to manage the response of western powers. Nato and European powers similarly do not wish to be dragged into deploying their own armed forces in Ukraine.

 

Robert M Dover is a Professor of Intelligence and National Security, University of Hull. A version of this article previously appeared in The Conversation and has been reprinted under a special arrangement.