Sweden's liberal virus strategy backfiring as death toll mounts?

A spike in novel coronavirus infections and deaths in Stockholm has raised questions about Sweden's decision to fight the outbreak without resorting to the lockdowns that have left much of Europe at a standstill.

Governments across Europe have closed schools and taken draconian measures to limit exposure to possible carriers, with Germany, for example, enforcing bans on more than two people meeting in public.

Among Sweden's Nordic neighbours, Denmark has closed its borders and shut its schools, as has Norway, while Finland has isolated its main urban region.

Yet Swedes are able to go to restaurants, get a haircut and send their children to school even as the number of confirmed cases and deaths has mounted, above all in Stockholm which accounts for more than half the fatalities.

An analysis of smartphone location data showed that while visits to public places has fallen steeply in most European countries, Sweden is bucking the trend.

But Sweden's liberal approach, which aims to minimize disruption to social and economic life, is coming under fire as the epidemic spreads in the capital.

"We don't have a choice, we have to close Stockholm right now," Cecilia Soderberg-Naucler, professor of Microbial Pathogenesis at the Karolinska Institute, told Reuters.

She is one of around 2,300 academics who signed an open letter to the government at the end of last month, calling for tougher measures to protect the healthcare system.

"We must establish control over the situation, we cannot head into a situation where we get complete chaos. No one has tried this route, so why should we test it first in Sweden, without informed consent?" she said.

Sweden reported 466 new cases on Saturday, bringing the total to around 10,151. The death toll has reached 887, with fatalities now running at about 15-20 a day, according to worldometer.

Sweden has a relatively high case fatality rate: as of April 8, 7.68% of the Swedes who have tested positive for Covid-19 have died of the virus. 

Neighboring countries, like Norway and Denmark, have case fatality rates of 1.46% and 3.85% respectively. The US case fatality rate is 3.21%. 

While Sweden’s elevated case fatality rate could be a result of its low testing rates compared to its neighbors, experts say Sweden’s laissez-faire approach could also be to blame.

Sweden seems to have failed to protect its most vulnerable citizens, in part by relying on speculative cultural theories. 

Authorities have argued that Swedes socialize less across generations than southern Europeans, and that Sweden could let the elderly self-isolate while merely slowing the spread of the virus among the rest of the population until so-called herd immunity is attained. 

Although herd immunity is not the official strategy, some officials maintain that there is no other conceivable way to stop the epidemic, praising the original British strategy that the United Kingdom later backed away from.

But it was never clear how this risky strategy of isolating the elderly while others got infected would work in practice. 

There are now alarming reports that the virus has spread to one-third of nursing homes in Stockholm, which has resulted in rising fatalities. 

While it is true that Swedes rarely live with their parents, older citizens are hardly isolated: The Scandinavian model simply outsources care from families to caretakers who visit dozens of clients every week. 

Caretakers are rarely tested for the virus but have simply been urged to stay at home if and shortly after experiencing symptoms.

Last week, Carl-Henrik Heldin, the chairman of the Board of the Nobel Foundation, wrote along with 2,000-plus medical experts and academics urging the Swedish authorities to take proper preparations against the outbreak. 

Some also wanted the capital, Stockholm, to be locked down after some 50 senior citizens died from the virus in care homes. 

The Swedish Prime Minister Stefan Lofven has since then warned about an impending crisis saying even if the country was not as badly hit as other European nations like Italy (over 15,000 dead) and Spain (over 12,000 dead), it did not guarantee fewer deaths.