Three Cs theory: How Japan tackles coronavirus

As the world tries to get a handle on the coronavirus and emerge from paralyzing lockdowns, public health officials have repeated a mantra: “test, test, test.”

But Japan went its own way, limiting tests to only the most severe cases as other countries raced to screen as many people as possible. Medical experts worried that the approach would blind the country to the spread of infection, allowing cases to explode and swamping hospitals.

It hasn’t happened.

Japan — the grayest country in the world and a popular tourist destination with large, crowded cities — has one of the lowest mortality rates from Covid-19 among major nations. The medical system has not been overwhelmed.

Even though at least 26% of Japan's population is over age 65 and at a higher risk of getting seriously ill with Covid-19, most people did not get sick. As of Sunday, the country of 126 million people had reported about 16,719 cases and 874 deaths.

Japan this week declared its state of emergency over, and many have linked its success to the Japanese government's messaging.

Instead of encouraging social-distancing practices like staying 6 feet away from other people at all times, the government told people to avoid the three Cs: closed spaces, crowded places, and close-contact settings.

On 9 March, Japanese medical experts refined its definition of a high-risk environment as a place with the overlapping "three Cs" - three crowdedness: closed spaces with poor ventilation; crowded places with many people nearby; and close-contact settings such as close-range conversations.

They identified gyms, live music clubs, exhibition conferences, social gatherings, and yakatabune as examples of such places. The experts also theorized that crowded trains did not form clusters because people riding public transportation in Japan usually do not engage in conversations.

Why 3 Cs

Japan didn't enforce shutdowns or social-distancing orders, but it encouraged people to avoid closed spaces with poor ventilation, crowded places with groups of people, and close-contact settings like one-on-one conversations.

The method, which leaves decisions about where to go and what kind of risks to take up to individuals, is designed to help minimize the spread of the virus while allowing life to continue, albeit with limits.

"We need to create a new lifestyle from now on," Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe said in a press conference on Monday. "We need to change our way of thinking."

Lockdowns in the United States have been framed as extreme, temporary procedures, while in Japan the three Cs have been framed as a new, permanent lifestyle for residents. This may bode well for the sustainability of the approach.

While some experts have lauded Japan's decentralized, bottom-up approach, others have expressed doubts that it works.

"The Japan conundrum is just the fact that if you don't test for it, you're not going to find a lot of cases," Jason Kindrachuk, an assistant professor of viral pathogenesis at the University of Manitoba, told Business Insider in March.

Kenji Shibuya, the World Health Organization's former chief of health policy, told Bloomberg in mid-March that either Japan had contained the spread of the virus by focusing on outbreak clusters or outbreaks haven't been found yet.

The Tokyo Review cited surveys finding that Japanese citizens were not as pleased with Abe's response to the pandemic. In one survey last month, Abe received a worse rating from his own citizens than several other world leaders, including US President Donald Trump, whose nation has by far the highest Covid-19 death toll.

But some Japanese residents have praised the three Cs system.

"The model allows for a certain level of economic activity and maintains people's freedom to move about, and as such is more sustainable over the long term than more burdensome models such as lockdowns," Kazuto Suzuki, a professor of international politics at Hokkaido University's Public Policy School, wrote in The Diplomat last month.