What is a safe zone?

Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina called for the creation of a “safe zone” in the Rakhine state of Myanmar for the Rohingya refugees in her address to the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA). But what is a “safe zone” supposed to be? Its origins lie within Article 23 of the Fourth Geneva Convention. The article stated that during a time of conflict, countries could declare areas “safe zones” for people who are not involved in the fighting. It usually means hospitals and other localities to protect the wounded, women, the elderly and children from war. However, in modern usage, a safe zone, as declared by the United Nations, is a vague concept that is thrown about regularly for its sound theoretical stance. They have the provision of including no-fly zones. An area designated by the UN as a safe zone in a conflict zone is conceived to protect civilians from military attack. However, there is no written definition of a safe zone by the UN, only precedents to refer to. In any case, safe zones have never yielded any good for the people they were set up to protect. Back in 1995, the UN declared Srebrenica a safe zone among six others in what used to be Bosnia-Herzegovina. The UN had even posted 300-400 peacekeepers to protect the Bosnian Muslims, in case the Serb forces defied the UN resolution. Srebrenica, a small mining town in the mountains, fell to the overwhelming Serb forces who proceeded to annihilate 8,000 Bosnian Muslims. It is by admission, considered to be the UN’s greatest failure till date. In 1994, the Hutu-Tutsi ethnic conflict in Rwanda led to the genocide of at least one million Tutsi people. Although there were safe zones throughout the country, the Hutu forces operated with impunity inside the areas. Most recently, safe zones were a key part of the conflict discussions by the pro-Assad and Syrian rebel forces in the Syrian civil war. The safe zones were planned to provide humanitarian aid to the refugees. As of September 21, a total of 422,000 Rohingya people have fled to Bangladesh from Myanmar. There are allegations of ethnic cleansing and genocide against the Myanmar armed forces. Given the precedence of safe zones and the condition prevailing in Rakhine, the Rohingya will be repatriated with the ashes of their houses, with more threats to their lives waiting for them. Without a strong UN peacekeeping force present, a “safe zone” is safe in name only. The UN would have to establish clear grounds in regards to the safe zone and the international community will have to ensure Myanmar abides by the terms of the resolution.