ESSAY

Old Dhaka’s heritage should not be built on a horse’s suffering

When I was a little girl, riding a Tomtom was one of those little fantasies I carried in my heart. Every time I saw a horse-drawn carriage pass by the streets of Old Dhaka, I would look at it with excitement.

It was magical in a way: the decorated carriage, the sound of hooves on the road, the idea of being inside one of those pretty vehicles. Someday, I have always wanted to go on that ride.

Growing up, however, changed the way I looked at them. The same sight that once made me smile now leaves me with an uncomfortable sadness.

I began noticing the horses: their bodies, their movements, the loads they pulled, and the conditions under which they were made to work.

I found myself wondering whether the experience I once dreamed of was coming at the expense of another living being’s suffering.

And that question has stayed with me: Why should an animal have to suffer so that humans can continue enjoying a tradition?

Horse-drawn carriages, or Tomtoms, as they are locally known, have been a part of Dhaka’s history for generations. They served an important transport function once, when there were no modern vehicles and public transport at hand. Historical accounts trace their popularity in Dhaka to the nineteenth century, when Armenian businessman G M Shircore helped establish the carriage business. They were once a familiar part of everyday urban life.

But cities evolve.

Dhaka is no longer the city it was a century ago.

We have buses, cars, motorcycles, CNG-powered auto-rickshaws, battery-powered vehicles, and countless other means of transportation. The practical necessity that once justified horse-drawn transport has significantly diminished.

Yet the horses remain on the streets, pulling carriages through traffic, noise, heat and overcrowded roads.

Still, we treat animals whose labour we continue to use for human entertainment and economic activity. What makes this situation even more concerning is that Bangladesh is not without a legal framework for animal protection.

Bangladesh does not lack a law on this. The Animal Welfare Act, 2019, bars the use of unfit animals for transport and forbids making them haul excessive loads or passengers. Offenders face up to six months in prison, a fine of Tk 10,000, or both. Yet on paper the horses of Old Dhaka are protected; on the street, they are not.

Who checks whether a horse is healthy enough to pull a carriage through Old Dhaka’s traffic? Who decides how many passengers are too many? Is there a vet anywhere in this system? And what happens to a horse when it goes lame or grows too old to work? Too often, the answer is that it is simply let go.

These are not questions for the carriage drivers. They are for the Department of Livestock Services, the city corporations and everyone else responsible for enforcing the law.

I also want to make something clear: this should not become a campaign against poor carriage drivers. Many depend on this occupation for their livelihoods. They might also be dealing with higher costs and weaker demand. It would be wrong to single them out, and it would be a mistake to ignore the economic realities behind the practice. The responsibility for change must also lie with the authorities.

A humane transition is possible. The authorities could introduce a gradual phase-out programme, replace traditional horse-drawn carriages with electric replicas, provide financial assistance and alternative employment opportunities to carriage operators, and establish proper rehabilitation and adoption arrangements for retired horses. Any transition must ensure that animals are not abandoned or moved from one form of suffering to another.

There are international examples worth examining. Cartagena, Colombia, has moved towards replacing traditional tourist horse carriages with electric alternatives. Its experience demonstrates that a city can retain the visual character of a historic carriage ride without requiring horses to pull passengers through its streets.

Dhaka may explore a similar model.

We do not have to erase history to make progress. The Tomtom can remain in photographs, museums, cultural exhibitions and carefully designed heritage experiences. Its craftsmanship, architecture and place in the history of Dhaka deserve preservation. But preserving the memory of a tradition is different from continuing a practice that may cause suffering.

Sometimes, growing up means questioning the very things we once adored. I still remember the little girl who wanted to ride a Tomtom. I do not want to dismiss her excitement or pretend that the carriages were never beautiful to look at. I simply wish that someone had taught me earlier to look beyond the carriage and notice the horse.

A city cannot call itself civilised merely because it has modern roads, impressive buildings and advanced transportation. Progress must also be reflected in how it treats those who cannot speak for themselves.

I no longer wish to fulfil that childhood dream if it means sitting comfortably while another living creature is forced to endure pain for my pleasure. Perhaps the most beautiful way to preserve Old Dhaka’s Tomtom heritage is to finally take the horse out of the equation.

Let the carriage remain. Let the history remain. But let the suffering end.

Anika Raisa is a law student at the Bangladesh University of Professionals.