20-30 enough for a place in the XI?

It was yet another agonising exhibition by the Bangladesh cricket team, especially the batting department, against the West Indies in the first Test at St. Vincent. Even though most of the Bangladesh batsmen got themselves in either in the first or the second innings, the visitors failed to gel collectively as the home side cantered to a 10-wicket victory yesterday on the final day of the first Test.  

Despite the defeat, the majority of the Bangladesh batsmen will console themselves believing that they have contributed something for the team and that their place is safe for the second Test. However, as the Bangladesh batsmen were unable to play as a team and convert starts into big ones, especially in the first innings when they were bundled out for 182, the visitors could not halt the hosts from romping to a convincing victory. 

It was an all-too-familiar scenario. Ever since the Tigers’ inception in Test cricket, the Bangladesh batsmen have fared well in one innings only to come up short in the next. This was also evident in the first Test against the West Indies. 

The first and second innings of Bangladesh in the St. Vincent Test match were contrasting to each other. After being dismissed for 182 in the first innings, the visitors regained some measure of respectability in the second innings as they posted 314 before losing all of their wickets to give the West Indies a target of just 13 runs. However, Bangladesh will be content knowing that they avoided another innings defeat.  

In the first innings, middle-order batsman Mominul Haque registered a fifty while skipper Mushfiqur Rahim was unbeaten on 48, two short of his 14th Test half-century. Opener Shamsur Rahman made 35 but was not able to prolong his innings. In the comparatively better second innings display, Mushfiq blasted his third Test century, Mahmudullah scored a much-needed 66 while opening batsman Tamim Iqbal made 53. 

Three batsmen – Imrul Kayes (nine and 25), Nasir Hossain (two and 19) and debutant Shuvagata Hom (16 and nought) – were not among the runs.

Hence, although some of the batsmen got runs, the major concern for Bangladesh is that they failed to do it all together in an innings which would have made one of their two innings a significant one and helped to save the Test match. Even though Bangladesh lost the Test match, most of the batsmen will feel that their place is ‘safe’ and that they have contributed something for the team. Therein lies the worry and the team is suffering as a result of the batsmen blowing hot and cold in both the innings.    

Tamim, one of the visitors’ most experienced batsmen, might have scored 53 but he played a casual shot whilst being clean bowled by spinner Sulieman Benn. He was out for one in the first innings.

The other opener, Shamsur, who made a century in the Tigers’ previous Test match against Sri Lanka at home earlier this year, started well in the first innings but soon perished for 35. A loose shot in the second innings led to his downfall as he made four.

The diminutive Mominul is unlikely to come in for criticism as he was extremely unlucky with both of his dismissals tinged with a considerable amount of doubt.

Kayes and Nasir will be targeting vast improvement with the former guilty of going for extravagant strokes when the situation demanded a calm approach.

Mushfiq and Mahmudullah though should be lauded for their contributions in the Test match. Mushfiq continues his development as a dependable batsman in Test cricket but it was actually Mahmudullah who required a significant score after a barren spell recently. Mahmudullah, inarguably, played the innings of his life as he made a patient 66 off 151 balls and shared a 130-run partnership for the fifth wicket with Mushfiq in the second innings which went a long way in ensuring Bangladesh did not go down to an innings defeat.  

The morale of the story is that the approach and attitude of the Bangladeshi batsmen towards the game needs to change. They have to come out of their mentality of securing their place in the side as it is the team which suffers the most.