The Bangladesh Cricket Board’s (BCB) decision to impose a six-month suspension on national all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan saw Bangladesh being divided into two parts.
A group believes that the BCB decision against Shakib was a gross injustice and termed the verdict a byproduct of ‘yellow journalism’. However, the media people denied the sentiment that ‘media played a negative role’ in the issue.
Arifur Rahman Babu, deputy sports-in-charge of national Bangla daily Shokaler Khobor and arguably the most senior cricket reporter, believes that there is no scope for yellow journalism in the Shakib issue. According to Babu, the media wrote and showed what had actually happened and that it had played no role in determining the punishment of the star cricketer.
“A reporter’s job is to hunt news and deliver the news,” Babu told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday. “What I experienced in the Shakib issue is that the board had many charges against him in the last six months. Most of the charges were off-the-field and related to his behaviour,” he added.
Babu stated that being a reporter he investigated the claims made by his sources. To clear the allegations, Babu contacted the concerned officials from the board and the team.
“So it was not only me but many reporters who received all these information and wrote it for their respective newspapers. So how can someone call this yellow journalism? Whatever was written in the media took place in reality, none of the information was fabricated,” said the senior cricket writer.
Babu believes that there is very little scope for yellow journalism at least in the sports arena of the country because at the end of the day the journalists working in this sector are well-wishers of sports and has tremendous passion towards their work.
Shakib’s punishment was apparently BCB’s harshest decision yet against a cricketer for indiscipline and many believes that it created huge noise because it involved the best cricketer of the country. But this is not the first time a cricketer was criticised by the media for indiscipline. The first time the current batch of national cricketers encountered severe criticism for indiscipline from the media was in November 8, 2010. In that year Bangla daily Kaler Kantho published a special page full of reports containing the wrongs of leading cricketers like Shakib, Tamim Iqbal, Mushfiqur Rahim, Mohammad Ashraful – mostly highlighting their indiscipline and gave suggestions as to how the board should act.
The newspaper, especially its sports department, faced criticism from the general public and also a certain portion of the media after this. Their act was termed ‘excessive’ and that they had targeted the cricketers to increase their readership. The reports had indicated that indiscipline would make Bangladesh cricket suffer in the coming years if proper measures were not taken.
Now after several years, a lack of action is hampering the country’s cricket – its best player will not be a part of the team in the next six months and might fail to create an impact in the 2015 ICC World Cup in Australia-New Zealand.
Sayeeduzzaman, special correspondent of Kaler Kantho, explained what he and his team had thought of the issue of indiscipline back in 2010.
“What we thought was that cricket is a team game and that discipline should come first,” said Sayeeduzzaman.
“A team will always have good players and mediocre players but what he had felt was that those good players of the team had started to expect privileges just because they were better players. We felt it was proving to be harmful for the Bangladesh cricket team four years ago. There was no other reason for that ‘one-page special report’ or it was not like we had issues with those particular cricketers,” he added.
Sayeeduzzaman thinks that the BCB is helpless most of the times on such issues because of the outcry of the general public and the media.
“There are times when directors and officials from the board spoke to us off the record on such issues and had termed the outcry a reason for silence and for being overlooked. But this was never of help as they are facing the consequences now,” said Sayeeduzzaman.
He believes if their reports were taken seriously four years ago rather than criticising them, the situation would have been better as precaution is always better than prevention.