At the Critics’ Awards for Arab Films this year, Elia Suleiman’s It Must Be Heaven was a clear front runner from the get go. The Palme d’Or nominated Palestinian film bagged the Best Film and Best Director awards when the winners were announced during the virtual Cannes Film Festival last month (June 22-26).
Two Tunisian performers received the Best Actress (Hend Sabry for Noura's Dream) and Best Actor (Sami Bouajila for A Son) nods for their heart wrenching renditions of hard working individuals whose momentary lapse of judgement snowball into mammoth jeopardies. Bafta winning Syrian documentary, For Sama, lost the Best Documentary award to a modest Sudanese film, Talking About Trees. Lion of the Future (Best Debut Film award at Venice Film Festival) winner, You will Die at Twenty, received the Best Screenplay statue to round up this year's winners.
I was lucky to be in the jury board, along with esteemed film critics- Alin Tasciyan from Turkey, Sydney J Levine from USA, Alissa Simon from USA, Pamela Biénzobas from Chile, Paulo Portugal from Portugal, Sharofat Arabova from Tajikistan, Viera Langerová from Czech Republic, and more.
As a part of the judging process, we were given online screeners of around thirty shortlisted films through Festival Scope Pro. The films could only be viewed once. One couldn’t even rewind more than 5 minutes to jog one's memory. So, paying full attention and taking notes (mental or otherwise) like in the physical festivals was a precondition in order to get the specifics right for evaluation and reviewing.
Every year, the Critics’ Awards collects the best films from the Arab world from the previous year. Most of these films had been in competition at Cannes, Berlin, Venice, Toronto and so on. As brilliant as most of the selections were, a few films etched a deeper mark than others for me; one was the Best Documentary winner (Talking About Trees) while another (The Unknown Saint) was omitted from the final round of nominations.
Talking About Trees
Four elderly members of the Sudanese Film Club decide to revive an old cinema. They are united by a common past- all of them enjoyed a film education in exile- in Germany, Egypt, and Russia. They repeatedly find themselves up against considerable resistance when trying to set up a state of the art film projection system. In their leisure, they talk passionately about cinema, their persecution and torture as oppositional artists.
The film is as much a tribute to cinephilia as it is to its four unyielding protagonists. There was something about watching a group of film-makers at the twilight of their lives staging a final showdown that made this documentary poetic, tragic and triumphant at the same time. These old men hadn’t made a film in a while, yet their lives revolved singularly around cinema.
Director Suhaib Gasmelbari’s mastery is in capturing the camaraderie of these rebellious men and marvelling at their glorious past through everyday mundane conversations; the camera almost never leaving the premises of the tattered amphitheatre where they are trying to screen Django Unchained. Although they can screen an old Charlie Chaplin movie without raising any concerns, a new Tarantino movie is not welcome by the local authorities who put one roadblock after another, making their discontent stridently pronounced.
The quartet leaves no stones unturned, even procuring a brand-new projector to enhance the cinematic experience. Suliman is particularly restless; filming with or posing for the camera being second nature to him. The exile might have cut their film careers short, but it would take an army to dissuade these indomitable cineastes.
The film had won the Original Documentary Award and Audience Award at the 69th Berlinale.
The Unknown Saint
You never forget your first. If that statement holds any truth, this film is extra special to me, as it was the first screening I attended at my first visit to Cannes. I was ecstatic to be able to see it again while judging for this award. With a second view, I could jot down the particulars to explain to my students how even Cannes official selections mimic a rough visage of the three-act structure. But then, naturally, I forgot where I made those notes and had to wing it during class.
This Moroccan film by debutant director Alaa Eddine Aljem is an absurdist film about a thief (Younes Bouab) who hides his loot in the middle of the desert under the guise of a grave. He comes back years later to find a shrine and a city built around that grave. Now he must find a way to retrieve his treasure for which he served in prison for years.
The timeless nature of this desert and the universality of religious blindness made the film surpass its cultural barriers and connect with a global audience. From the camera, the lighting, the sound to the writing and the acting – there was no trace of a novice in this film.
The characters were minimalist yet well-rounded, each with their own clear goals and conflicts. It is a film our upcoming filmmakers can study to understand how an absurdist film can have structure and substance without compromising on the director’s artistic vision.
Even the sub-characters, with their separate storylines, had a short but clear character arc. For instance, a snob of a barber-cum-dentist (Ahmed Yarziz) in that new small town becomes the town’s hero by making gold teeth for the shrine guard’s beloved dog. Another unorthodox arc appears when a new doctor arrives in that town only to find out he has nothing better to do than to prescribe paracetamol. He takes up an illegal hobby just to survive the boredom. The humour in this drama is thus subtle and clever, opulent with subliminal subtexts.
The film was selected for the 58 International Critics' Week in Cannes.
These two films represent two ends of a wide spectrum of films we saw as a part of this competition- a winning documentary and a fiction that didn't attract enough votes to compete in the final round. After spending over sixty hours exploring these diverse human stories, it was hard to say goodbye to the Arab deserts. Whether the film won an award or lost the nomination, each film shines in its own merit and erects a distinct shrine in our hearts to immortalize its memory. Only unlike The Unknown Saint, we know what these shrines stand for.
The article was first published in Celluloid