SAP seeks probe into contract awarding process

German Multinational Software Corporation SAP AG’s local partner has urged the government to launch an official investigation into a procurement process of software for the National Board of Revenue (NBR).

S.S. Solutions Pvt. Ltd, SAP’s Gold Partner, claimed the process to procure an Integrated VAT Administration System (IVAS) Commercial-Off-The-Shelf (COTS) Software Package went through “irregularities and lack of transparency” as they submitted the a formal allegation on Sunday.

They filed the complain with the NBR as also apprised the Ministry of Finance and Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) of the alleged irregularities in the process to award the contract of the World Bank funded project to a French company BULL SAS.

The NBR has sent the proposal to the Cabinet Division for necessary approval to appoint the French company as consultant to introduce the online system for value added tax payment, which is scheduled to begin from July next year.

S.S. Solutions had quoted a price US$1.4 million lower than what BULL offered, according to the written letter of request signed by the firm’s Chairman Kazi Salahuddin, who is also the president of Bangladesh Football Federation (BFF).

The system will be introduced under the VAT and Supplementary Duty project worth Tk551.59 crore where World Bank will finance Tk449.78 crore and the remaining cost will be collected from local sources.

According to the letter, the NBR selection committee has disqualified SAP to clear the passage for BULL SS to get the work. “I’m surprised and amazed with the decision,” Kazi Salahuddin told the Dhaka Tribune yesterday. “How a renowned company and global market leader like SAP has been disqualified,” he questioned.

NBR sources said the French company BULL scored high in technical and financial offers analysed by the eight-member tender evaluation committee. SAP AG also raised question why they have not been informed about the ground based on which the selection committee disqualified them.

They also pointed out observation about a report by American information technology research and advisory firm, Gartner Inc, titled “critical capabilities for integrated tax system COTS products”  that reads 63% of the world’s transaction revenue touches an SAP solution and SAP has approximately 280 customers globally who are using the core PSCD (public sector collection and disbursement).

Bangladesh Bank, the World Bank’s Dhaka office and multinational companies like central bank of Bangladesh, is a client of SAP while major multinational companies like Unilever Bangladesh, BAT, Nestle, Axiata, NOKIA, Siemens, Youngone Aventis and Novartis, and local corporate giants like Bashundhara Group, Rahimafrooz Globaat Ltd, Square Pharmaceuticals Ltd. and most of the pharmaceutical companies were among their major clients in Bangladesh.

On the other hand, the same report says BULL team is of relatively small size and allows BULL to manage no more than two implementations at a time. Reportedly, they have no client in Bangladesh so far.