‘Commodifying deer will mean more, not less, poaching’

Forest officials claim the Deer Rearing Policy 2014, currently being formulated by the government, will decrease deer poaching and reduce human intervention in the Sundarbans, but conservationists are not convinced.

The new policy, which aims to accommodate a growing demand for deer as a luxury pet and for venison, has failed to persuade environmentalists, who say commodifying the animal will create new incentives for poaching.

Conservation experts worry that it will be difficult to determine whether live deer or venison available in the market is sourced from licensed farms or protected wildlife stocks.

“The deer rearing policy will help halt deer poaching from the forest as well as reduce human  intervention in the forest. Both of these issues are harmful for the Sundarbans mangrove ecosystems,” Ratan Kumar Majumder, deputy chief conservator of forests, told the Dhaka Tribune.

But Wild Team Executive Director Professor Anwarul Islam said allowing deer farming would not bring good results but would rather encourage poaching.

The government should properly enforce the existing Bangladesh Wildlife Protection and Safety Act, 2012 to stop wildlife poaching as well as human intervention in the forest, he said.

Prof Anwarul, also a zoology professor at Dhaka University, said poachers not only hunt deer but are also often caught with tiger parts.

In addition, he said, they cut down different types of trees from the Sundarbans, which is extremely harmful to the forest. Bangladesh is considered a noteworthy site of wildlife poaching especially for tigers, spotted deer and other animals.

The illegal trade in animals and animal parts from Bangladesh primarily targets the demand for wildlife parts in Asian and European markets.

The new policy will allow interested parties to rear a maximum number of ten deer as domestic animals or as livestock for venison without seeking a farm license.

But those interested in establishing a deer farm – defined as rearing more than 10 animals – must apply to divisional forest officials for a permit.

The licensing fee to set up a farm in metropolitan areas has been set at Tk20,000. At the district level, the fee will be Tk10,000.

To stock their farms, deer farmers must buy breeding stock from the Forest Department, public zoos or existing licensed farms. The cost of each animal has been fixed between Tk15,000 and Tk25,000.

The new policy allows activities related to rearing deer – hand over, sale and consumption – at a  distance beyond a threshold 30 kilometres from the forest.

Farid Uddin Ahmed, chief executive of Aranyak Foundation, which works for sustainable forest management in Bangladesh, said the proper implementation of the Wildlife Protection and Safety Act, 2012 would be the best thing for the preservation of the Sundarbans.

He expressed doubt that the government could effectively verify the source of deer or venison in the market – whether the are wild or farm reared – and expressed worry about the scope for abuse.

In Bangladesh, wild spotted deer is only found in mangrove ecosystems like the Sundarbans. Currently around 70,000 spotted deer roam the Bangladesh Sundarbans.

Several thousand more roam Nijhum Dwip, an island in Noakhali district, after being released there by the Forest Department.