‘Divisive’ EIA for Rampal plant gets approved upon ‘conditions’

The Bangladesh Power Development Board has secured approval of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for its proposed 1,320MW coal-run power plant at Rampal in Bagerhat amid severe concerns of the environmentalists and ministries.

The Department of Environment (DoE) gave the EIA green signal after eight revisions and imposing a number of conditions to protect the World Heritage Site, declared by the Unesco, and river Pashur which is a sweet-water dolphin sanctuary.

The final environmental clearance for the project would be given after implementation of the project “only if the project is installed with proper mitigation measures suggested to check pollution,” Md Shahjahan, additional director general of the DoE, told the Dhaka Tribune.

The PDB claims that it will use supercritical technology and ensure “proper mitigation measures” to cut emission of hazardous gases including carbon dioxide, fine particles and fly ash, and properly dispose the solid and liquid wastes.

Another government body, the Centre for Environmental and Geographic Information Services (CEGIS), has prepared the EIA for the PDB.

The DoE had approved the assessment report just before Eid holidays, said the official, who deals with the project on behalf of the environment regulator. However, no official declaration or statement was issued by the DoE in this regard.

“We took almost three years to authorise the EIA,” he said. “We are aware of the environmental concerns. Nevertheless, we have given the approval only after getting a clear picture of the project, suggesting adequate mitigation measures and putting a number of strict conditions,” Shahjahan said.

The DoE would follow the plant’s activities, including emission of toxic gases, through an online monitoring system, he added.

Before approving the EIA, the DoE incorporated in the EIA the observations of ministries concerned, independent experts and common people.

Unesco never gave opinion on the project. But the Ramsar Convention Secretariat, an international convention to which Bangladesh is a party, in a letter in 2011 expressed concerns and inquired the environment and forest ministry about the power plant and an anchorage at Akram Point, and construction plan for a ship yard and silo in the forest area.

Following the email communication, the forest department, the DoE and the shipping ministry expressed concerns and suggested that proper mitigation measures were taken to save the Sundarbans. The industries and food ministries refrained from giving their opinions.

Experts, environmental groups and independent researchers, who have been demanding that the project be shifted to somewhere else far from the Sundarbans, had rejected the EIA at the mass hearing held on April 12.

A public platform “National Committee to Save the Sundarbans” was formed last month to stand against the project that also involves an anchorage at Akram Point of the Sundarbans – within the boundary of reserve forest – to unload coal.

Ambiguities and misinformation in the EIA and the government’s desperation to implement the project are the other reasons of public displeasure. Academicians, environmentalists and activists vow to resist the project as they point out many inconsistencies in the EIA.

Earlier on July 5, the National Committee to Protect Oil, Gas, Power and Port announced a long-march programme from Dhaka to the Sundarbans for September 24, protesting the plant project.

Law enforcers charged batons on locals of Rampal and the activists who joined the protest.

The joint-venture project of Bangladesh and India at Satmari Katakhali of Rampal has created much hype because of having potential threats of air and water pollution in the adjoining residential areas, the river and the Sundarbans.

Indian state-owned National Thermal Power Corporation (NTPC) will build and operate the plant, which will use imported coal preferably from Indonesia or Australia.

Initiated by the PDB in 2010, the project got location clearance from the DoE on May 23, 2011 upon 12 conditions, one of which barred development work in the wetland within the project area until the final approval of the EIA.

However, all necessary preparations have already been done while three petitions that challenged the project are pending at the High Court. Acquisition of 1,834 acres of land for the project, land filling, and signing of agreements related to project implementation, investment and power purchase are already complete.

The government has plans to inaugurate the plant’s construction work next month. It will take four years to complete the first unit of 660MW while six more months for the other unit. The BDP Limited, a firm run by Bangladesh Army, is currently conducting the land filling job.

Despite the government’s firm resolve to implement the project saying it would not be harmful, the EIA elaborates on some concerns, including environmental and social impacts of the project. Hence, it suggests mitigation plans after evaluating the impacts. The EIA also covers hazard and risk management, and detailed plans for environmental management and monitoring.

On emission of carbon dioxide, a key factor for global warming, the EIA says: “Releasing of CO2 is the major resultant pollutants after using high efficient modern thermal power plant. However, socio-economic improvement will be the significant insights for the south-west region in future.”

A 1,000MW coal-fired power plant produces approximately the same amount of global warming as 1.2m cars, according to a study conducted by the Union of Concerned Scientists, a Massachusetts-based non-profit advocacy group.

The EIA anticipates that the proposed jetty at Akram Point in the Sundarbans and movement of ships and other vessels will cause oil spillage, air and noise pollutions affecting the flora and fauna of the ecologically important forest. Artificial lighting at the plant and in vessels will also be harmful for the nature.

According to the document, the project area is about 14km north-eastward of the Nalian Range of the Sundarbans and 4km away from the Ecologically Critical Area boundary. The project area has 95% arable land within a 10km radius and it will also affect fishing, cattle and birds and animals of the Sundarbans.

It was once a part of the forest but was occupied by the settlers. The other site considered at Labanchhara of Khulna deemed not feasible considering population density and impact, and was dropped.

Asked about shifting of the plant site, Md Shahjahan said: “Yes, it is true that the plant is close to the Sundarbans. But what is the problem with that? Why was the Mongla Port built [near the Sundarbans]? There are many cement factories and even an Export Processing Zone [EPZ]!”

He asserted that the Sundarbans would in no way be harmed if the mitigation measures were taken properly.

“They [plant operator] cannot do whatever they like. They also cannot change the mitigation measures mentioned in the revised EIA. We will look into everything while giving the environmental clearance,” the DoE official added.

The government has plans to install several other large coal-based power plants in Chittagong and Cox’s Bazar.