Environment courts sit idle due to lack of complaints

The Dhaka Divisional Environment Court is either dealing with criminal cases or lying “inoperative” because of lack of environment-related cases, even if green activists claim that the number of anti-environment activities is on the rise across the country. According to court sources, it received only four cases early this year and 54 in the last five years. The number of cases filed form 2007-11 was 276. Conceding the matter, Firozur Rahman Montu, special public prosecutor of the court, said: “We give importance to environment-related cases. But the court is now conducting criminal trials due to a lack of a sufficient number of cases concerning the environment.” The only Environment Appellate Court of the country situated in Dhaka also remains “inactive” for the same reason. During an inquiry by the Dhaka Tribune, it was found that only seven cases – two of the Dhaka Divisional Environment Court and five of the Chittagong Divisional Environment Court – are pending with the appellate court for hearing.Echoing Firozur Rahman, AFM Rezaul Kabir Hiron, public prosecutor of the appellate court, said they were too dealing with criminal cases owing to a dearth of environment-related complaints. And, it is the same with the Chittagong court that received only 85 cases in the past five years. Although campaigns by environmentalists against pollution are increasingly gaining momentum in the country, the numbers denote that affected people are reluctant to seek justice due to snags and complexities in the environmental law, they said. Complicated legal procedures apart, they identified delayed disposal of cases, low rate of conviction and lack of adequate courts as the causes of the reluctance. The government formulated the Environment Act-1995 in a bid to conserve the nature by checking pollution, but it is now limited to nominal drives of the Department of Environment and its minor punitive measures against offenders. Dr M A Matin, general secretary of Bangladesh Poribesh Andolon, said:  “People are not well informed of the environment court due to a lack of awareness campaigns. The government ministry concerned is not sincere about making them aware.” In addition to the Environment Appellate Court, the government has so far set up three environment courts in three divisions including Dhaka, Chittagong and Sylhet although the act stipulates that there has to be at least one court in each division. Urging the government to set up environment court in every upazila, Dr Matin said: “The four environment courts set up across the country do not suffice to resolve cases of all districts.” The activists also alleged that there was no specific plan of the environment ministry and environment directorate for dealing with environmental issues facing the country. The environment court was introduced to hear cases concerning environmental pollution. Initially, a complainant was not allowed to directly lodge a lawsuit demanding compensation. A 2010 amendment to the act, however, cleared the way for anyone to file complaints and seek reparations from those responsible. The court sources said many people were ignorant of this provision.