Race to the finish threatens vulnerable country goals

With just a day to go before the global climate summit in Paris comes to a close, a big question mark hangs over whether the final agreement will be legally binding or voluntary.

Wednesday evening’s draft text revealed several disagreements including over whether the global temperature rise target should be below 1.5 or 2 degrees Celsius.

Crucial planks such as the finance mechanism, loss and damage measures and preferential treatment for vulnerable countries were also hotly contested by the representatives of the world’s governments.

Temperature goal

On the temperature rise goal, the draft still contained three options – below 2°C above pre-industrial levels, well-below 2°C above pre-industrial levels and below 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.

Only one option will ultimately make it to the final Paris agreement.

Developing countries, climate-vulnerable countries, Least Developed Countries (LDCs), Small Island and Developing states (SIDS) and the African countries, were pushing for the 1.5°C target.

The BBC reports that the so called “high ambition coalition” comprising over 100 countries, including the EU, Norway, Mexico and Colombia were now backing the 1.5°C target.

Even the US was on board, with lead negotiator Todd Stern calling for the 1.5°C target to be recognised in the eventual agreement.

But vulnerable country negotiators said this last minute compromise will likely come at a cost.

There were suggestions that if developed countries agreed to the 1.5°C target, the issue of loss and damage compensations would, in consequence, be struck from the draft.

Speculation ran rife at COP21 that loss and damage negotiations would be subject to hard ball tactics.

Saleemul Huq, director of the International Centre for Climate Change and Development (ICCAD),  told the Dhaka Tribune that developed country pressure for such a trade-off, between the temperature goal and loss and damage measures, was likely.

Loss and damage measures

An earlier draft saw the loss and damage clause, using the phrase “compensation and liabilities,” removed before it was sent to minister-level negotiations.

Developed countries, including many of the world’s major polluters, have traditionally preferred less ambitious temperature rise goals.

Kamal Uddin Ahmed, secretary to the Ministry of Environment and Forests, told the Dhaka Tribune he was not sure whether the demands of high climate risk countries would be met.

Echoing Saleemul Huq’s comments, he said today’s talks would reveal which way the negotiation’s final outcome would go.

Observers said it appeared as though the bottom had fallen out of the negotiation on the bottom line.

The finance negotiation is arguably the most important portion of the talks.

On the eve of the long-awaited final agreement, there was no clear indication about who would take responsibility for financing or how much money would be committed to climate funds.

To get an idea of just where the talks stand, here is an extract of Wednesday’s working draft text:

“Developed country Parties shall provide [new,] [additional,] [adequate,] [predictable,] [accessible,] [sustained] and [scaled-up] financial resources to assist developing country Parties with respect to both mitigation and adaptation. Other Parties may on a voluntary, complementary basis, provide resources to developing countries, including through South-South cooperation initiatives.”

Brackets signify that a word is contested and has not been agreed upon.

Saleemul Huq explained that words in brackets meant that there was still uncertainty in the financial process.

Moreover, the draft text had removed language about balancing financing between mitigation and adaptation, a crucial demand of the developing countries.

Preferential treatment for vulnerable countries

The developing countries are often the most vulnerable to climate change but have limited access to resources to tackle the negative impacts of global warming.

Members of civil society who attended the Paris climate summit that began on November 30 expressed frustration that so much remained in the air with just a day left in the negotiations.

They said the draft text failed to address many issues including preferential treatment and financial support for developing countries and countries most vulnerable to climate change effects.

These principles had previously been secured in the text of the Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDRRC), a statement of the core principles of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC).

They said although the volume of the draft text had been reduced, nearly nothing had been agreed upon.

Golam Rabbani, senior research fellow at the Bangladesh Centre for Advanced Studies (BCAS), said: “Preferential treatment is the essence of the UNFCCC, but we do not see references to this in the new draft. So I do not see any special outcome from this conference.”

Ziaul Haque Mukta of the Campaign for Sustainable Rural Livelihood said: “If global leaders fail, Bangladesh will become more vulnerable.”