The COP21 presidency was struggling hard to bring out a final draft for the much-expected climate agreement in Paris, but could hardly reduce the differences among the parties until last evening.
The presidency was scheduled to circulate the final draft yesterday afternoon, based on which the agreement is expected to be signed.
“Differences on few issues among the countries and different groups could not be reduced yet,” a member of the Bangladesh delegation told the Dhaka Tribune asking not to be named. The problem mounted during the overnight deliberations Wednesday night that continued until early yesterday.
“The coordinators of different country groups were working on the gaps in an effort to making a final draft to be circulated tonight [yesterday],” he said. The UNFCCC issued a tentative schedule of circulating the final draft at 7pm CET (Central European Time), but the observers were highly sceptical about the schedule.
The final draft, however, will again be circulated among the Parties to take their feedback before going for an agreement.
As negotiations enter the home stretch, the process has not yet succeeded in dealing with all the crunch issues.
The Paris ambition mechanism, the loss and damage language, and scaling up commitments by 2018 – all these issues need to be sorted out.
Asked about the update of the conference at a press conference at the COP21 venue yesterday, US Secretary of State John Kerry said: “Well, we’re working away. Today’s obviously getting down to the critical stage, and we had a very constructive meeting. We feel very good about the conversation we’ve just had. We need to work on language, and that what most of today and tonight will be.”
Meanwhile, a coalition of over 100 countries, led by the USA, was formed to steer an ambitious agreement. The USA has formed, but the ambition has not been made clear.
“I am not sure whether it is a tactic to delay the negotiation process,” said Dr Munjurul Hannan Khan, joint secretary and project director of CASE. “What we say is to ensure the limit of temperature rise by 1.5 degrees Celsius.”
He added that the LDCs want to see finance, technology and capacity building issues addressed in the agreement with preferential treatment for the LDCs and the SIDS.
On Wednesday evening, Fabius noted that 75% of square brackets, denoting areas of contentions, had been removed and he emphasised that every effort had been made to retain balance and avoid prejudging outcomes. He also explained that it was not the final version.
A member of the Bangladesh team said the square brackets had now came down to around 600 from the around 1,500 in the document with which the COP21 started.
The text reflected the divides that have been evident since the start of COP, but crucially, Parties again expressed their faith in the COP president and the process he proposed for taking negotiations forward.
Differentiation was a common issued raised by developed and developing country groups. A common refrain was that the text on this cross-cutting issue remained “unbalanced.”
The EU and Australia stressed the need for an agreement that took account of changing circumstances. Interventions from the Small Island Developing States (SIDS) were particularly vocal in calling for recognition of their special needs.
Well articulated wording in the statement suggested that there is a sufficient body of countries pushing for an ambitious outcome over the coming 24 hours, but the question still remains whether the Parties could show sufficient flexibility in related areas of finance, technology and capacity building to unlock the differentiation challenge.
Negotiators worked late into the Wednesday night and early yesterday as they sought to find further convergence on the unresolved issues.
Despite the mixed reaction from Parties on the night and in the remaining hours, it would be needed to stay strong in seeking an ambitious climate agreement, if the COP21 President Fabius is to fulfil his promise to “leave nothing behind.”
The negotiators must now be willing to find common ground on the remaining key issues – the long-term goal, the five-year review mechanism – starting from 2020 onwards – and climate finance.
To ensure an effective outcome in Paris, the heads of delegation need to do three things – must secure ambition that is consistent with the scale of the climate challenge, secure consensus amongst the 196 governments negotiating an agreement, and secure an agreement that sends a catalytic signal to accelerate the creation of a thriving, clean economy.
“There are still too many red lines on the table. Compromises need to be made, but there are two kinds of compromises: the ones we want and the ones we don’t. There are ones that will threaten ambition, and ones that will work to deliver the kind of deal we need,” said Alix Mazounie of RAC France.
This deal needs three things. It needs loss and damage because without that, the more vulnerable will be left behind; finance, because without it, the poorest will be left behind; and ambition, because without it everyone would be left behind.
“It is essential that we have a big political moment like this in 2018 to review and scale up our progress. Countries will only act if the eyes of the world are upon them,” Mohamed Adow, Christian Aid.
“Now those leaders need to start picking up the phone and work together to turn those words into action,” Jennifer Morgan, Global Director of WRI’s Climate Program, said yesterday morning
On Wednesday, the French presidency released a revised text, which was explained to parties that the aim of the 29-page draft was to provide an overview of progress made and to focus attention on the outstanding “political issues.”