‘Decarbonisation needs to be ensured beyond Paris’

Can you tell us about the issue of energy and emissions in the context of climate change negotiations?

Energy production is a major contributor of greenhouse gases. Traditionally in negotiations there has been a heavy focus on energy for mitigation – through decarbonisation, more sustainable forms of transport etc. The internationally agreed target is to try to keep emissions to a level that will limit increase of temperatures not more than 2 degrees, which is considered the safe level. That’s basically what has been agreed so far in COP.

What is the main hurdle for reaching a consensus?

At the core of the disagreement is the issue of fairness. Developed countries want to make sure all countries have an emission reduction target including developing nations, which was not the case in Kyoto Protocol. On the other hand, the developing countries argue that since the developed countries have largely been the source of the emissions in the past, the developing countries shouldn’t be constrained for a problem they didn’t cause. However, developed countries refute that the majority of growth and emissions will happen almost exclusively for developing countries in the future. The OECD is starting to peak so their emissions are decreasing. So, developed countries being the only ones having mandatory emission reduction targets will not be enough to reduce global temperature rise in the future when developing countries will be the major emitters.

In this context, what are the prospects of decarbonisation and assistance from the richer to poorer nations?

The poor countries want to see the rich countries pay to decarbonise their energy systems and shift towards a cleaner energy system as they are the least capable countries in terms of technical capacities. The developed countries themselves have started to shift away from the dirtiest sources of energy, and a lot of the technologies are developed in developed countries. There certainly seems to be a willingness to help countries make that transition, but when it comes to the money commitment, it is not that clear.

What are the alternative sources of finance for transitioning to green energy?

In the international capital market there is a lot of money but it sits with private banks with investors. We at UNDP are trying to understand the conditions to allow this capital to be increasingly invested in cleaner energy sector instead of coal or gas, and increasingly in developing countries where these investments are needed. Right now the risk is that due to the huge energy demands developing countries will want to meet their needs for dirty energy, so finance for green energy is essential to prevent that from happening.

How competitive are renewable energy sources? And what are some of their major shortcomings?

Renewables have become a lot more competitive in terms of lifecycle costs over the investment lifecycle, which is a good thing. But there are still big issues to be solved before they can substitute conventional sources such as coal. Storage is a major issue. Moreover, they are still very inefficient and very expensive. So as a first step, we are trying to integrate renewables into existing energy systems – blending them and increasing the share, for instance by connecting solar firms to power grids.

What is the paradigm shift that is needed to create a more favourable situation for renewables?

A major problem is that the world still works on the framework Thomas Edison developed in the 19th century. There is a centralised power plant that generates the electricity and then a network that takes the electricity to where it is needed. Such a system is very capital intensive so many developing countries cannot afford it. Moreover, there are significant technical losses within the system.

So the paradigm shift that needs to happen is to move towards a distributive generation model, with much smaller units of generation such as smart grids, bringing them closer to where electricity is needed. This is a completely different way of producing and using electricity.

This is also more resilient because with a centralized system if power goes out everyone is without power, but that is not the case with this system.

However, for this to happen, the utilities that run the grids need to adjust their business model because currently they see it as a threat of business being taken away from them.

What is your view on reaching the 100% renewables goal?

Renewables are the ultimate solution, and 100% renewables are where we eventually want to be. But before we get there, we can achieve a lot through energy efficiency. So before thinking of substituting current sources, we need to think of reducing the energy needs in the first place by increasing efficiency. Immediately jumping to renewables is expensive. The investments needed for energy efficiency are typically lower as well. Focusing on efficiency will buy some time as renewables develop further.

What should COP21 achieve with regards to energy?

I would like to see a reactivation of carbon pricing. Businesses react to incentives and it gives them an incentive to reduce emissions. Carbon taxes, preferably in addition to carbon pricing, would be very effective.

At the core there needs to be a price on carbon, to internalise the cost of carbon. I would like to see some clear indication of that from COP, ideally a binding agreement on this matter. However binding itself isn’t enough, unless it is enforced. So, implementation needs to be ensured beyond Paris.