Negotiators struggled to reach a consensus on key issues like adaptation, finance and loss and damage measures, with just half a day remaining before the draft text of the climate agreement is handed over to ministers at the official beginning of COP21 today.
There were sharp differences among countries as negotiators intensified their engagement to reduce the gaps as much as possible yesterday.
“We’re seeing negotiators take more openly political positions: that’s provoking sharper confrontations, but it’s also giving an understanding of where potential trade-offs might be,” said Kelly Dent of Oxfam.
The French presidency spent yesterday and the day before conducting consultations with all of the delegations before proposing a way forward today for the second week.
“The draft text should be ready by tonight,” COP21 president, French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius, told a press conference at the climate conference venue in Paris yesterday afternoon, intensifying the pressure on the negotiators.
“It will not be reasonable to extend the deadline … it should be ready by Friday night,” he categorically said, replying to a question. “The ministers will require time to examine calmly the text (before finalising the Paris Agreement).”
The streamlined document of the texts expected today - the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) called the day an “Action Day” - could give ministers an effective technical tool for working through the complex political negotiations.
Earlier in the morning yesterday, the co-chairs released two negotiating texts – the first one of 48 pages and the second of 38 pages – which were mainly based on compromising options and, more specifically, bridging proposals from the co-facilitators of the issue discussion groups. The first text was shortened by four more pages by the afternoon.
“My desire is to achieve the maximum number of compromises to finalise the draft,” Fabius said, declining to disclose the issues of difference for the sake of the negotiation. “It would not be appropriate to discuss specific issues at this point … the two texts are complementary and supplementary and many brackets were deleted.”
Civil society observers say the co-facilitators’ version of the text includes potential compromises on critical issues like loss and damage and adaptation, which could provide a way forward for developing and developed countries to reach some common ground.
“There was positive movement on loss and damage – a red line issue for vulnerable countries – which now has a bridging proposal set out that builds on a lot of the work done on the Warsaw mechanism,” said a statement issued by Climate Action Network members in Paris.
Some of the things in the loss and damage proposal were picking up the concerns of vulnerable countries, although it was still up for debate whether they were likely to remain in the final text.
On many issues, there are still difficult political trades to be made to ensure that the deal doesn’t just end up as the lowest common denominator.
The review on temperature target, which resulted in strong arguments for a 1.5 degree limit as a safer way to protect all communities, ended up getting blocked from being sent to ministers, primarily by the Arab Group with Saudi Arabia leading.
However, ministers have a formal agenda that gives them the option to address this issue without the blocked report. So they still have the option to affirm and adopt the 1.5 degree goal.
“I hope we’ll achieve the target,” Fabius said, replying to a question about the stalemate.
UNFCCC Executive Secretary Christiana Figueres, who also spoke at the press conference, pointed out that there was a target range of between 1.5 and 2 degrees Celsius. “The main issue is the reduction of emissions.”
Replying to another question, she said developed countries must shoulder the finance because of their historical responsibility. In the provision of finance, there are “supplementary and complementary” proposals, she said.
“There is not a single factor that can be moved alone … there is no single issue that is currently on the table that can be said to be final,” Figueres said, in response to a question.
Last night, the EU recognised that the $100 billion in pre-2020 finance is a floor, and they also, alongside the US and Japan, agreed that they would consider a collective contribution target for post-2020, if the donor pool increases.
The US has made it clear that new contributors will not have the same level of responsibility – outlining a difference between the obligations of rich countries and the donations of those who are able to do so.
“Parties need to start compromising now – not at the 24th hour when everyone’s sleep-deprived and the clock has run down,” Greenpeace’s Kelly Dent said.
There has not yet been enough movement for developing countries to be assured that they will get the financial support that they need to adapt to climate change and reach long-term goals.
Discussions in spin-off groups – interspersed by larger contact group meetings – continued throughout the day yesterday. There was mixed progress with adaptation and transparency moving ahead and the mitigation text being streamlined.
As expected, finance has taken centre stage as the key sticking issue.