How replacement creates displacement in the hill tracts

A devastating landslide in the Chittagong Hill Tracts in 2017 led to a serious stocktaking about land settlement policies that were increasing landslide risk and pushing vulnerable ethnic minorities to the brink. But have the lessons been learned?

The Bangladesh Needs Assessment Working Group’s (NAWG) Report on Landslides was published on June 19, 2017. 

It found that 18 emergency shelters had been opened to accommodate over 4,500 displaced people after the terrible landslide took place on June 13 that year. 

In Bandarban, more than 500 families took refuge in emergency shelters or safe spaces including schools. 

Eight hundred additional families did so in Rangamati. 

Rekha Chakma was one of them.

But three years after the landslide displaced her family, she left Bangladesh. 

Rekha’s child, Prince, died that tragic day, just after her birthday. 

That moment was described by Rekha’s aunt Muktasree Chakma in an article titled “Live from a ghost town: Landslides in Rangamati is a wake-up call for the country.”

Muktasree said: “We were among the lucky ones. But my niece Rekha, who lost her four-year-old daughter Prince in the landslide, wasn’t lucky. 

Neither were the 150 persons whose bodies have been recovered from the landslide.”

Prince’s body was found around 5pm that day. She was on her neighbour’s lap. The neighbour’s wife had tried to save her. 

The  reservice workers wept when they found their bodies.

Rekha’s brother Dr Dhankar Chakma said: “My sister tried to resettle here ... build a house again.

But the trauma of a lost child and fear of landslides haunted their family.

They felt they had to leave the area, and then the country too.

Now they are living in a monastery of Kolkata, India.”

Dhankar said Rekha had left but had taken her surname Chakma with them. 

But he added that maybe her children would not be able to carry the community’s name anymore. 

He worried that they would not carry out the Chakma rituals anymore. 

Circumstances may not permit them to do so.

An accident snatched away a family member and perhaps also their identity, he said. A well-established family had lost everything because of the landslide.

He claimed many people like Rekha had to leave their birthplace, showing social and community injustice too.

Death and displacement toll

According to the Switzerland-based Internal Displacement Monitoring Center, in 2019 around 4,443,000 people were displaced in Bangladesh.

The displacement happened due to di erent natural disasters and their consequences. The number of displacements increased rapidly over the last three years – it was 78,000 in 2017.

The 2017 landslide caused around 200 deaths. 

NAWG stated that the disaster killed an estimated 160 persons, including 115 persons in Rangamati alone. 

Local people claimed the death toll was closer to 200.

According to the Chittagong Divisional Health Office Control Room Report, a total of 187

injured persons were admitted to local level hospitals. Approximately 85% of the cases were recorded in Rangamati.

Among the 78,000 displacement cases recorded in 2017, around five thousand took place in Rangamati.

Displaced people primarily took shelter in government-provided shelter homes.

Is this community injustice?

Disaster specialist Gawher Nayeem Wahra thinks there is an ethnic dimension to the landslide situation.

He stated that this type of disaster and the resulting displacements are nature’s retribution for destroying the natural equilibrium. 

But he went on to explain that a large number of people are settled in hilly areas who do not know about the lifestyle of the hill tracts: they come from the plains. 

Their livelihood has destroyed the natural equilibrium. 

And the ultimate sufferers are the ethnic minorities.

Natural injustice creates racial and social injustice too, said Wahra.

He has stressed the situation of ethnic minorities whose numbers are dwindling. 

Displacement creates a strong impact on those communities and ethnic groups.

He said the spotlight is always on the largest ethnic groups – the Chakma, Marma, and Tippera.

“Those are the largest minorities, but ethnic groups like the Mru,

Tanchangya, Chaks, Kumis, Kuki/Lushais, Khyang, Pancho, Bangoji, and Mrung are sometimes over- looked. 

Day by day their number decreases due to various disasters and displacement,” he explained.

Wahra describes the landslides of the Chittagong Hill Tracts (CHT) as a man-made disaster.

“We have settled the displaced people of Noakhali and other districts who are victims of river erosion. Later, unplanned development and extravagant tourism have eroded the hill tracts,” he said.

He said that from a bird’s eye perspective, Rangamati looks like a skeleton. 

Natural beauty and nature are damaged in various ways and that a ects the life of ethnic minorities who understand better how to manage the land.

Settlers are also the victims of disasters and their numbers are greater than the ethnic groups.

Wahra explained that all of this was happening due to ignorance.

He pointed out that hills in Mizoram, in neighbouring India, do not face landslides. 

Their hill-dwelling communities are not at risk because they have not broken the natural equilibrium.

The resettling of displaced people is di cult, he said. 

Most go back to their place of origin, despite the risk. They are on the set- tling and resettling circle, he said.

First, time must be given for nature to heal – and it may take a long time. Then the resettling of the displaced has to be tackled. He proposes to resettle displaced people in any safe area but said that a district like Rangamati is too small.

But the scarcity of safe plain land is another big issue, he said.

Administration is ready

“If rain starts in Chittagong, we start preparing ourselves to protect Rangamati’s people of the hill tracts. This type of hypervigilance started after the devastating landslide of 2017,” Rangamati District Commissioner Mizanur Rahman said.

He said: “It is tough to stop landslides permanently but we are working to protect the people. We are also working to develop the area. 

But around three thousand people are living at risk. A huge number of people were displaced at that time. Around four hundred families’ lives were devastated at that moment. 

The government took initiatives to settle them but still many lives are at risk.”DC Mizanur Rahman said plains peoples who have been settled in the hills often lived in ways that create a risk of landslides.

“They do not know how to live in the hills and they create risks for other ethnic groups, too. But the government is working to stop the displacement of this particular area.

They are resettled but a few are displaced for various reasons, ethnic people are also there,” he said.

He said the government was working for safe resettlement and in the coming future there wouldn’t be any displacement. Government

has many projects with various organizations and they are working to control extravagant tourism which causes harm for the hills, he said.

There is a silver lining 

Environment journalist Iftekhar Mahmud advocates for the proper economic and academic development of ethnic minority communities. 

Especially those who are vulnerable. He said economic development an halt displacement. 

He mentioned the case of Japan after the 2011 Tsunami. 

He pointed out that their developed economy stopped displacement. 

While he admitted that Bangladesh’s economic development was not like Japan’s, he said we could take the example of Noakhali. Remittances work against displacement in that district. 

Economic development has given them the chance to create safe shelters on their own.

According to the Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies and the International Labour Organization’s 2017 survey, the poverty rate in the country is 22.3%, while the poverty rate in the three hill districts is 51.1%. This can be changed by earning remittance. “This is a proven fact,” Iftekhar Mahmud said.