Syed Waliullah’s Lalsalu, later translated into English as Tree Without Roots, is a long harangue about the state of affairs of the then East Pakistan. Waliullah confines Bangladesh’s predecessor East Pakistan to a rural setting called Mohobbotnagar, whose inhabitants submit themselves to a conman named Majid, who, in a desperate attempt to escape poverty and hunger, assumes the custody of a grave that he claims belongs to a revered figure in Islam.
In Mohobbotnagar, Majid’s unquestioned authority, aided and abetted by his accomplice’s political authority, forecloses the possibility of social reforms. Waliullah reduces religion to Islam (and vice-versa) and sets that religion up against progress, education, and economic and civil liberty -- in short, everything considered good.
Lalsalu distinguishes between the political and the religious, the latter of which is at the pivot of the exploitation industry. Published in 1948, Lalsalu simultaneously captures and sets the tone for urban-middle-class attitude towards religion. Questioning this attitude leaves one vulnerable for name-calling: Brainwashed, uneducated, reactionary, medieval, Razakar, terrorist, and whatnot.
It is difficult not to share Waliullah’s concerns about religion’s instrumentalization for seemingly irreligious motives, although readers familiar with the works of scholars like Talal Asad, Brent Nongbri, and Timothy Fitzgerald, among others, would be at unease with equating Islam with this religion. But perhaps a more likely complaint is that Waliullah takes a strand of popular religion, if it can be called religion at all, and presents it as the representative of religion as a whole.
In Lalsalu, there is no religion that is progressive, supports education, empowers the women, and, indeed, can potentially be not mere superstition.
This sentiment underlies the hostility many Muslims taking their faith seriously often encounter in Bangladesh’s urban-middle-class space. The self-declared enlightened liberal minds among our midst have for viewing religiously oriented individuals as either a passive victim of religion or an active deceiver.
This in no small part contributed to activating hitherto passive believers to salvage their reputation. Turning passive believers into conscious activists. Islamism privileges modern, rational interpretations of Islam, displacing traditional communal forms of Islamic practices, including Majid’s.
However, the Majid’s of are far from being wiped out. Instead, they have been replaced by Zakir Naiks.
In contrast to Majid, Naik is a western educated medic marshalling science against Islam’s detractors in fluent English, albeit in an Indian accent. Lalsalu critiqued religion for its stance against education and science. Naik and the modern Muslims enrolling in ever greater numbers in the country’s top engineering and medical schools dealt a severe blow to this narrative.
Hardly a Bangladeshi phenomenon, the strong connection between education, specially in science, and violent extremist Muslims, as well as Islamists in general, have resulted in multiple opinion pieces, journal articles, and books. Diego Gambetta and Steffen Hertog note in their 2016 volume Engineers of Jihad that 46.5 percent of violent Islamists they studied had received higher education and, of those whose academic discipline could be known, 58.9 percent were in STEM.
Waliullah’s strategy of picking on Muslims for their reluctance to embrace modern education backfired to give rise to the modern Islamist class, which although mostly non-violent, differ from pre-modern Muslim society in the sense that Islamists are conscious activists unwilling to listen to an authority figure without rational proofs.
The “engineers of Jihad” ensure that Waliullah halts nagging Muslims about their passivity and unwillingness for social change. The Muslim modernity encapsulated in Islamism seeks western education, rights, jobs, equal treatment, and perhaps more importantly, a say over the direction of the society’s political future, unsettling the secular political settlement.
The failure of Lalsalu’s wholesale rejection of Islam necessitates a new Islam that will undo some of the corrosive effects of this Muslim modernity. The imperative to put the genie back in the bottle leads the urban-middle-class psyche to find an ally in a former enemy: Folk religion.
Asked to oversee Muslims’ return to their passive believer state, folk religion privileges superstition over Salafi rationality, cults over Islamist political party, and economic and political exploitation over a politicized Muslim subjectivity. On the other hand, Islamism prompts the secular psyche to be overcome with a profound nostalgia about the good old days of Muslims, smoothing out the contours associated with such times.
As many Muslim communities across the globe, including in Bangladesh, rekindle their love for the cultic figures not so long ago condemned for using religion as a cash cow, we are likely to witness more political quietism, inegalitarian practices, and submissiveness and a general rise in Islamophobia. There is little surprise that UAE funds neo-traditionalist Muslim voices, Narendra Modi visits the mausoleum of Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti, and Shahab Ahmed marshals Sufi wine drinking against the legal, puritan Islam.
Since the mission to eliminate religion backfires and generates a threatening Muslim modernity, that mission is replaced by a project of domesticating and managing religion. Phenomena such as Farhad Mazhar’s folk religion and Qawwali concerts hint at the shift from a war on religion towards one on politicized Muslim subjectivity, which, left ungoverned, can fundamentally alter the world order.
Islamism is hazardous; it provokes Muslims to be the agents of history -- that too on a religious ground. However, the way we push back needs to be measured, lest we head towards an even more perilious course.
Md Ashraf Aziz Ishrak Fahim has a first degree in International Relations and Global Affairs from Mahidol University, Thailand, and an MA in Social and Political Thought from the University of Leeds, UK. He is currently a graduate student of Contemporary Islamic Studies at Hamad Bin Khalifa University in Qatar. He can be reached at mdfa48907@hbku.edu.qa