Quod erat demonstrandum

Until the city corporation polls in Dhaka and Chittagong on Tuesday it had been more or less conventional wisdom among the chattering classes that the BNP had made a huge blunder by boycotting the January 5 national elections last year.

The BNP argued that elections held under the supervision of the ruling AL were bound to be rigged and thus they refused to participate, handing the elections to the AL in what essentially amounted to a walk-over.

The difficulty the BNP faced was that they had no way to prove their hypothesis.

The fact that they had pre-emptively withdrawn from the elections made it impossible to definitively prove their contention, and however likely or believable their claim of impending rigging, it remained an unproven hypothesis.

Not anymore.                               

What the April 28 mayoral elections have proved conclusively is that the BNP was absolutely right when it said that elections under a partisan government would be rigged against the opposition.

It is possible that the BNP might have won even with the rigging, had they stayed in until the end, but that is not the point.

The point is that by doing precisely what the BNP said they would do, the AL have essentially conceded the correctness of the BNP point and no longer have a leg to stand on.

Now who can argue with a straight face that the BNP should have taken part in the January 5 elections?

The main point of contention between the two parties appears to have been conclusively settled: it is clear that we need a caretaker government or some kind of neutral interim arrangement for the holding of credible elections.

Lest anyone think that rigging elections is the sole provenance of the AL, please recall that the BNP has rigged its own fair share of elections, and if it were in power there is no reason to think that it would be any more scrupulous than the AL.

No, the lesson from April 28 is not that the AL is uniquely untrustworthy when it comes to elections, but that no elected Bangladeshi government can apparently be trusted to hold free and fair elections.

In short, the conditions that required the institution of the caretaker government back in 1996 still pertain, and without such a system in place to guaranty fairness and impartiality, elections in Bangladesh are worthless.

It has been demonstrated that a political government cannot be trusted to hold fair elections. It has been demonstrated that the Election Commission is neither independent nor credible, and remains quite unequal to the task of ensuring fair polls.

Thus it seems unlikely that the BNP will ever again contest elections under an AL government, and who could blame them? Unless the government reinstates the caretaker government -- and there is no cause to think it ever will -- then we are stuck with the kind of one-party elections we saw on January 5.

But where does that leave us? It leaves us with the unhappy realisation that representative and participatory elections are finished in Bangladesh for the foreseeable future. But if elections are finished, then what price democracy? 

These mayoral elections were the last chance for getting the two-party political system we have had in place for the past few decades back on track. They were the last chance for the AL and the BNP to try to reach some kind of workable compromise.

But what they have shown us that the AL is not willing to take a chance on losing an election, even elections as inconsequential as elections for a mayor with very little power.

The same thing happened with local government elections last year, but one could argue that the stakes for the government were too high then, and that they needed to retain control over the local government or face problems with their governance agenda.

But even with the stakes so much lower this time, they were still not willing to take any chances on the mayoral elections.

The best argument the government could possibly have made for its stance on January 5 and moving forward would be to ensure that elections held under its supervision were totally free and fair.

Who knows? Maybe their candidates would have prevailed. The poll that the party ran and published on the eve of the elections showed them all winning handily. They should have had the courage of their convictions.

Imagine for a moment that the AL had allowed the elections to be above board. Imagine if the AL had sent out the word to the EC and law enforcement as well as all their party-men that come what may there was to be no violence, no intimidation, no rigging. There would be zero tolerance from law enforcement and within the party for any irregularities. Let the chips fall where they may.

Then the AL could at least have argued that the elections settled the issue, once and for all, as to whether it was fit to administer elections or not. Had the BNP prevailed, the government’s case would have been even more unanswerable. The argument would have been won.

Unfortunately, the government did the exact opposite. Q.E.D. 