What democracy?

The violent anti-government movement, which started in the first week of January, continued for almost three months. There was enormous loss of life and property. As per a sector-wise study carried out by Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD), the total loss, in financial terms, during the two-and-a-half months of hartals and blockades, was Tk4,900cr.

From January 5 to March 22, blockade violence killed a total of 92 people (75 general citizens) -- 61 were killed in arson attacks -- while over 1,400 were injured.

The aim of the movement was to create pressure on the government to press home their demand for a mid-term poll under a neutral administration. A good number of people, both inside and outside the country, feel the national election held on January 5 last year was not free, fair, or participatory. Most political parties boycotted the election in the anticipation that it would, in fact, not be free and fair under the incumbent government.

That those who boycotted would demand a re-election and try to wage a movement if their demands were not met is natural. But the way it was carried out, especially the violence and the loss it inflicted on public life and property, cannot be accepted.

Presently, the country is being governed without any structural mechanism that would ensure answerability of the government. Institutions responsible for making the government accountable have become ineffective in reality. By changing guidelines laid down in the constitution, both the government and the opposition in parliament have been brought under the control of single command centre.

Due to constitutional barriers (as a result of certain actions by the government), the officially declared opposition party cannot oppose any proposal of the government in parliament.

Parliament, is supposed to be the most effective place for guaranteeing accountability of its executives. Our parliament has been made totally incapable of performing that job. As a consequence, a non-accountable one-party dictatorial rule is what Bangladesh is seeing now.

This type of parliament naturally breeds autocracy. Autocracy fails to provide good governance, and corruption flourishes as an inevitable consequence. As they say: “Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely.”

There had been an inherent flaw in ensuring accountability in our system of governance all along -- it has not just cropped up all of a sudden after the last general election. If that election had been free, fair, and participatory, the lack of accountability would not have been solved. Even if acceptable elections can be held in the future, it might not guarantee a non-repetition of what has happened now.

But holding a free, fair, and participatory election offers the scope for the public to make effective evaluation of the government on its performance. The election poses as the ultimate instrument of accountability, on an overall basis, to be accepted or rejected by the people.

By successfully holding the controversial elections on January 5, some concern has been created that the incumbent government can continue to stay in power without the proper mandate of the people and may even extend its tenure indefinitely by repeating the same strategy.

Many people are alarmed at the prospect that the country might be moving towards perpetual autocracy.

Under these circumstances, the demand for a modification of the system and of holding a free, fair, and participatory mid-term election may be considered an effort to move away from an autocratic mode of governance and re-enter the path to democracy.

It is alleged that people carrying out the movement have been doing so exclusively for their lust for power. This is not totally untrue; it may be considered a half-truth. Even if their demand for a free and fair election is achieved, they would be able to ascend to power only if voters choose them against the incumbent. 

The practice of democracy, accountability, good governance, and corruption are all inter-related. Corruption is inversely proportional to the other three factors, meaning corruption falls with the rise of all or any of the others, and vice versa. The practice of democracy, accountability, and good governance move up and down simultaneously. The extent of corruption can be used to measure good governance, as a higher degree of corruption indicates a fall in the other factors.

A fall in democratic practices, by-passing accountability, deters good governance and encourages corruption to flourish. Deficits in democracy create suffering of people by depriving them of their due rights and by misusing and misappropriating public funds and resources.

Transparency International Bangladesh in their publication on the service sector corruption survey 2012 reported an estimated total of Tk21,955.6cr paid by the public as bribes to receive due services in 13 sectors.

This survey was only on small bribes at the grassroots level. It did not include alleged bribery in mega projects, money being siphoned out of state-owned banks, public property being dished out, etc. These petty bribes may be considered the tip of the iceberg -- the actual figure of losses due to corruption is likely to be several folds bigger.

The cause of most unnatural deaths like bus, launch, or train accidents, building collapses, robberies, etc can be attributed to a lack of good governance and the spread of corruption. Public loss due to the persistence of an autocratic system of governance in terms of life and property continues to accumulate.

When it becomes unbearable, mass movement becomes inevitable for survival.

However, as I have already mentioned, only having free and fair election may not solve the deficit of democracy that we see now. It will require a modification of the entire system and our political culture, for which a national consensus is necessary.

Politics is supposed to be directed towards the benefit of the people. No political strategy should be such that it creates public harm, misery, and uncertainty.