The UK election is acquiring colour, more of an entertainment variety than political. Already cross-dressing brothers, stealing each other’s policy clothes, a wicked uncle, fairy godmothers, and someone -- it is hard to tell whether the wicked witch of the north, or another, more powerful, fairy -- have all arrived on stage. And it isn’t even pantomime season!
There has even been plenty of scope for the traditional cries from the audience of “behind you!” and “oh yes you did!” “oh no I didn’t” when appealed to by the players. Good clean fun. Or not.
Political “brothers,” Ed and Dave, who between them might as well be described as the “Ugly Brothers,” have spent the past few days exchanging clothes.
Dave, at present the stronger one, is very busy playing to the gallery, scattering goodies for the audience, including over a million homes for sale at over 30% discount, and promising no more taxes on family homes worth less than a million pounds, all whilst explaining how his “brother” has been naughtily misrepresenting him as planning to sell off the last of the family silver ie the National Health Service.
Meanwhile, the younger “brother” is laying claim to a financial credibility that most people think ought to belong to Dave, who has been claiming the credit to saving family finances that Ed and his friends had frittered away.
For Bangladeshis, the Wicked Uncle, “Nigel,” may be of greater interest, since he certainly wants to put a stop to any more handouts to foreign countries, and whose immigration policies suggest some admiration for Idi Amin’s way of dealing with too many South Asian migrants in Uganda by simply bundling them up and shipping them home.
No one is very sure whether the young leader of the Scottish Nationalists, Nicola Sturgeon, is a potential Fairy Godmother or a Wicked Witch, ready and willing to break up the Union, and willing to support anyone who might help; but, no doubt, as the election draws nearer, that may be revealed.
Two other pretty ladies, one dressed in Green, and one wrapped in a red Welsh Dragon, seem to have walk-on parts, although their potential role in the development of the plot of the show is still unclear.
It would all be rather fun, perhaps, if it weren’t so serious. And if those ominous and lengthy shadows cast by the wicked uncle and the indeterminate Northern influence seemed less menacing.
The word “pantomime” has an ancient Greek origin, and through centuries of tradition embracing masques, morality plays, and other forms -- many of which utilised humour to make meaningful points -- may have eventuated at today’s children’s entertainment at Christmas, but have, throughout history, contained serious messages and ominous threats.
Even Shakespeare’s plays have included such serious warnings. Macbeth, Akroyd explains in his biography of the great dramatist, was written around Lady Macbeth’s important message on the subject of treason, evidently referring to the recent plot of Guy Fawkes to assassinate King James (“every one that does so is a traitor, and must be hang’d”). The play itself may have been a real populist entertainment, but also, like most, it is open to serious interpretation.
The audience at Christmas pantomimes certainly look to be humoured and entertained, but it is sometimes worth a little time reflecting on what message is contained within. No less so in this British general election.
Amongst the goodies being thrown from the stage by Ugly Dave, at least two seem more than a trifle dangerous to more alert observers. The promise to sell, at discount, another one and a quarter million of the country’s already much depleted stock of social housing, may put a stop to the growing trend amongst younger, less affluent voters, to rent homes, rather than buy, by considerably depleting the stock of homes available to rent. But it may well also facilitate home ownership to a younger middle class generation of Margaret Thatcher’s ideal of “a home-owning democracy.”
Greater homelessness, however, seems inevitable. Promises to house more of Britain’s rising numbers of the homeless, and disposing of social housing stock, appear mutually contradictory.
The greatest contradiction, however, appears in Dave’s evident readiness to take sides with Wicked Uncle Nigel Farage and his associates, who are rather indistinguishable from Dave’s more “fundamentalist” supporters, who readily invade the stage at every opportunity to demand that UK severs its ties with all foreigners, especially those based in Brussels. It may, of course, simply be a part of the entertainment; sleight-of-hand also has a great tradition.
Indeed, only six months ago, Dave took every opportunity he could to tell everyone that the Union of Great Britain and Northern Ireland meant “a thousand times more” to him than any consideration of dumping connections in Europe.
But polling consistently shows people in Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland -- who are, with smaller populations and greater rural communities than England, the most frequent beneficiaries of “European” funds -- wanting to remain part of Europe. Dave has, so far, failed to explain how, if the far greater number of voters in England -- also the heartland of Farage’s friends -- manage a majority for exit, he can meet expectations as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, not only England.
Of course, it is the growing suspicion that Dave, in fact, feels much more comfortable associating with the social cream of England, where, together with the offspring of ancient land grabbers in Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland, he was educated in the socially desirable tradition: Eton and Oxford.
The polls, sadly, have pointed to his need, should the audience acclaim his supremacy on May 7, to consider the impact on the Union that, he said, was so important to him, of, presumably with reluctance, sheepishly following only the wishes of the English.
For most of the audience, the pleasure of a relatively harmless spectator sport akin to the Colosseum of ancient Rome, but without the blood -- so far -- is so lacking in attraction that the real implications may await discovery when it is far too late to rectify the position; at which point there may well be, not just figurative, but possibly even, actual, blood, in the arena.
Exit from the Union, Dave made clear to the Scots, means exit for good. It is not hard to imagine that the attitude of the European Union will be expressed in similar terms, should the voters of England lead that charge to the EU exit. Sadly, all politicians, at least in Europe, have, somehow, managed to acquire the reputation for seldom meaning what they say, so, who knows?
Uncle Nigel’s determination to limit, if not stop financing the development of countries that, whilst they may become competitors, could also become burgeoning markets for British businesses -- if there are any left -- may also, potentially, become another ominously looming shadow in the aftermath of May 7.
Breaking up as a Union, cut off from Europe, with a declining defence capacity that will inevitably reduce its appeal to the United States as a “partner,” England could yet return to its state of a millennium ago, divided within itself, and vulnerable to everyone. And that could include its own neighbours.
For historians, perhaps, a fascinating prospect; privileged to witness a return to the ancient Kingdom of Northumbria as rampant threats to the Southern and Eastern folk of Sussex and Wessex. The UK may yet bear witness to Karl Marx’s maxim, “history repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as farce.” If the devolution of powers in 1998 was a tragedy, what comes next may well have more elements of farce.