In bow to the tongue-twisting nature of certain Standard English enunciations, the urban saying here goes: “Denial is not a river in Egypt.”
But it sure is a five-act play in today’s dramatic Bangladesh.
Since the horrendous incident of the plethora of sexual assaults on Bengali New Year’s Day, I have read social media posts from an otherwise respected private television journalist that the perpetrators could only be the usual suspects in his eyes … “Jamaat-Shibir.”
Not to be outdone, an occasional newspaper columnist living in the land Down Under is convinced that the vivid video footage from the horrible evening shows that only “non-secular” forces can be responsible.
I should be more forgiving of these representative efforts at intentional blindness considering that the first reaction from the regime’s own detective branch head was “no such incident happened.”
Just like the disappearance of Salahuddin Ahmed and Ilyas Ali didn’t happen. Or the pepper spray attack inside a former prime minister’s office compound. Or the petty acts of cutting off her utilities, water supply, and food deliveries. Or the attack on her motorcade in broad daylight this past Monday.
It is, however, more than merely static denial. It is a masterfully choreographed, well-rehearsed, and utterly predictable dance of deniability with vividly sequential acts which goes into an encore production every time someone big or small is victimised by elements -- official or otherwise -- close to the ruling regime.
Act one involves plain denial; nope, nothing happened, all is an imagination. Act two kicks in when the absurdity of act one is too much even for sycophants to bear, and revolves around protestations of “yes it may have happened, but we have no idea who did it.”
Then evidence in the form of hushed utterances, recollections of witnesses, and audio/video shots that slowly begin to emerge, seguing the play directors to move into act three. The third act of the play is a promise of a full investigation by the very sentinels who were supposed to be keeping a watch in the first place, while claiming that there is no need for an independent investigation, let alone a judicial one.
As the patience of the few investigative journalists wears thin with this umpteenth “investigation” and the public demands answers, begins act four: The repeated assertion that anyone still interested in seeing justice done is a paid agent of some nefarious entity which itself is responsible for the original act of malfeasance in order to embarrass the ever-so-benevolent rulers.
By this time, frustration, exhaustion, and sheer brow-beating has silenced all but the most dogged of victims and their advocates; those who still didn’t get the message are dealt the coup de grace through act five: Anyone still trying to focus on such unimportant things must be part of an “anti-liberation” conspiracy and trying to foil the war crimes trial. Move along now, nothing happened, we didn’t do it, and don’t care who did.
Those who are tempted to find a silver lining in the originality of this five-act play should take pause. This is a very Dholaikhal version of what governments resting on pillars other than electoral mandates have done through the ages, and continue to do so. Admitting even the possibility of misconduct -- intentional or otherwise -- by the increasingly small group of elite from whose support legitimacy is drawn, can be highly detrimental to the perceptions of eternal durability.
The symbiotic relationship between such a regime, its official constabulary, and its unofficial street enforcers is the cornerstone of its legitimacy and, thus, is defended with often irrational zeal by the beneficiaries of that regime’s largesse in the commercial circles, media houses, professions, and elsewhere.
How many websites can they shut down through legal actions or extra-legal death threats in the middle of the night? How many editors can be locked up for asking tough questions? How many dissenters can be abducted, never to be seen again? 160 million is a huge number to mow down … even with the most sophisticated, well-oiled, and unified state executive-legislative-judicial-bureaucratic machinery augmented by car-smashing thugs above the law. Yahya Khan found that out when there were only 7 million.
Five-act dramas devoid of any relation to reality wear thin even for the most enthusiastic of audiences. The history of a defunct East Bengal, an erstwhile East Pakistan, and an independent Bangladesh proves it time and again.
Either in a few years or a couple of generations, even the most absolutist of political playwrights, like those once found in the former Soviet satellite states, go into the dustbin of history. Betting against the tide of history of our people is tempting when in power surrounded by sycophants, but hardly a wise thing to do.