It is said that elections are the feasts of democracy. The sights, sounds, and smells of boisterous canvassing, the jockeying for popular support, the strategising and polling … that is potent cocktail for a heady adrenaline rush for political junkies.
Right out of college, and through graduate school, I spent plenty of time in the thick of such heady campaigns, canvassing, doing telephone polls, putting together events and whatnot. One of my favourite mementoes is a picture with former President George HW Bush taken in Iowa when my friends and I were camped out there during a fall helping out his son President George W Bush in his own quest for the presidency.
I get the excitement being generated for the city corporation elections in Dhaka and Chittagong, trust me I do. The possibility of elections seems to have already reduced the tension and gloom in the political atmosphere and provided a valve for pent up political energies to be channeled in slightly more wholesome pursuits.
But the analyst in me has the usual tough question: What exactly is the end-purpose of a mayor and councilors in the city corporations in Bangladesh? And that is even with the rather overtly optimistic and naive assumption that the elections will be free, fair, and transparent, and that the individuals getting the most votes will assume and keep office.
As I write this, balloting is underway for the mayoral and city council elections in my modest North American city of about 400,000 people. A competitive race -- ostensibly non-partisan like Dhaka’s and Chittagong’s, but with party supporters obviously involved -- between two strong candidates for mayor and several for each of the open city council seats makes for an interesting evening watching the returns.
But it is more than just interesting: These results will have an effect on the lives of city dwellers. How so? Well, for starters, the mayor and city council are collectively responsible for the city’s police and fire departments, including the hiring, sacking, equipping, and disciplining members of these emergency response forces.
City planning, building inspections, municipal courts, and zoning are also in the exclusive purview of the municipal government as is the provision of water and sewage lines. Throw in the maintenance of the city’s parks, roads, airports, and bus service, and you get a picture of a mayor and councilors who are actually responsible to their fellow citizens for some serious quality of life issues.
And what do the mayors of Dhaka and Chittagong do? Or for that matter, what exactly do the ward commissioners do?
Let’s go beyond the symbolic and prestigious. Apart from attesting certificate copies, supervising the dilapidated garbage-hauling mechanism, and contracting out vegetable and cattle markets, is there anything else for which the municipal corporation mayors and councilors in Bangladesh are responsible to their citizens? City planning -- or what passes for it in Bangladesh -- is the province of the different development authorities, there are no city parks left worth the name, roads are dug up by every department from RHD to PWD and filled by nobody, Wasa and DESCO handle water and power respectively (if hardly responsibly), while the police and fire services are controlled with an iron fist by the home ministry.
Heck, even the constant renaming of major city thoroughfares is dictated by the sensibilities and sycophancies of cabinet members.
In other words, with the exception of the ability to impose certain limited levels of property taxation, the notion of local government simply does not apply to the municipal corporations of Bangladesh in any meaningful manner.
Such practical impotence perhaps explains why the current regime has summarily dismissed and jailed the elected mayors of several other metropolises whose only crime seemed to have been a refusal to join the ruling coterie.
I am not contending that the titular prestige of being a mayor or ward boss in a capital city isn’t important. It is. But it should and can be effective as well as important. For starters, the Constitution of Bangladesh provides a pretty direct mandate for establishing effective local governments at all levels-municipal, upazilla, and district.
That particular mandate has been followed with just as much fidelity as the other constitutional mandates regarding a national ombudsman, an independent judiciary, and free speech.
Wouldn’t it make sense to have municipal governments that do a little more than attest school leaving certificates?