In most instances, I would be the first to bemoan the UK’s drift towards the American-style, big budget, media-heavy electioneering campaigns. Not so when TV debates were introduced during the last election.
This, I thought, is what we’ve been waiting for, a proper platform to engage people in politics again. A formal debate where leaders of the main parties could be held accountable and couldn’t hide behind obfuscation, spin doctors, and parliamentary privilege (an age old act that protects MPs from all laws when speaking in parliament, essentially allowing them to lie).
David Cameron (the current prime minister, then, the challenger) said time and time again that debates were essential for our society. “I’ve always wanted these debates to happen. I mean they happen in every country. They even happen in Mongolia for heaven’s sake and it’s part of the modern age that we should be in.” (The inherent racism aside, I wholeheartedly agree.)
The first debates we had were a huge success. A three-way platform was agreed between the three main parties with three debates, the first half of each debate focused on a particular theme (domestic, international, and economic affairs), before general issues were discussed. The questions were not disclosed to the leaders before the debate. Public interest in the debates was huge, with the first debate watched by 9.4 million people.
It also led to Nick Clegg (the leader of the third party, the Lib Dems) seeing a huge boost in popularity. Normally sidelined in the press and in political commentary, this new platform allowed them to put forward their progressive platform and separate themselves from the drudgery of the two main parties.
It was democracy in action, a beautiful thing to see. It is worth noting that after seeing an upswing in their vote share and forming a coalition government, the Lib Dems went on to break nearly all of their election pledges made during the debates.
However a blow was struck for engagement and democracy. We saw the highest turnout since 1997, when all trends were showing voter apathy decreasing, these debates turned the tide.
Fast forward to 2015. A proposal is sent to the prime minister outlining three debates, one with the leaders of the Conservative and Labour parties, a second also including the Liberal Democrats, and a third including UKIP.
The Green Party wrote to the broadcasters demanding that they be included -- they declined; Cameron quite rightly pointed out that with the increase in small parties’ support, many people are suggesting that they should also be included in the debates and that he won’t take part unless the Greens are included.
Thanks to the prime minister’s ultimatum and a 275,000 strong petition, the broadcasters relent and put forward a new proposal including the Greens, as well as the SNP (Scottish National Party) and Plaid Cymru (who only stand in Wales) followed by debates with the three main leaders, and then lastly, the main two. A fair compromise that allows everyone a proportional voice.
It seems now, however, that Mr Cameron is singing a different tune and refuses to take part in any debates that include less than all party leaders. A cowardly move intended to reduce any airtime he has to share with his main rival Ed Miliband (the leader of Labour).
The broadcasters take the bold move of threatening to empty chair the prime minister and push forward with the debates without him. This puts them in a sticky situation; being independent, they are not allowed to make any sort of political statement, but also have to give equal time to all major parties.
Going ahead without the PM could have been seen as a political statement, it certainly has enough ground to be challenged in court. Not having the debates at all could just as well be seen as not providing the parties with a platform to speak to the public.
I was hoping the broadcasters would hold their nerve, as the collapse of the debates would be solely seen as the PMs fault. With multiple polls showing the electorate believe he acted in a cowardly manner, the debates would go ahead even if he refused to take part.
Sadly, it seems that in the last few days, they have relented and agreed to a single full seven-way debate. This is capitulation at its worst, allowing the PM to flex his political power to cow them into agreement.
I cannot lay the whole blame at the feet of the broadcasters however, what is needed now (as with the media regulator) is an independent body tasked with deciding the format of the debates with all parties signed up to abide by its decision.
This would lead to far less airtime, and, in this writer’s case, far less print space taken up with meaningless posturing and politicking and more time spent on the real issues at hand.