Are we ready for freethinkers?

The killing of Avijit Roy by unknown men carrying meat cleavers within the Dhaka University campus at the end of the Ekushey Book Fair is certainly an episode that completes the month of February on a sinister note.

But as more facts from the past surface, we find that threats against the self-proclaimed free thinker were made several times before.

Obviously, these were not taken seriously; otherwise, Roy and his wife would at least be surrounded by friends.

One issue that keeps on bugging me is that if the blogger and his outspoken views were so popular, then why didn’t anyone present during the incident make an effort to stop the crime?

For those who come to the DU campus, it’s a well-known fact that police are always present at two specific spots: The TSC intersection and by the residence of the Vice Chancellor.

In addition, a Dhaka University micro-bus, commonly referred to as the Proctor patrol car, moves around the campus to ensure outsiders do not crowd the university roadsides.

Reportedly, men in blue were too slow to react. Also, no one chased the killers as they ran away! So many people on motorcycles …

The picture-capturing moments after the attack, with the blogger lying unconscious on the pavement in a pool of blood and his shell-shocked wife asking for help, came out in several papers and, if the mood of the whole scenario can be gauged, it becomes clear that people around her seem too paralysed to do anything.

A man in uniform, carrying a gun, is seen at a distance, whereas common sense states that by that time there should be police everywhere.

At some other time, this killing would be treated as a singular incident, but with the country facing political turbulence mixed with intransigence from all sides, there is an attempt to link it to the ongoing crisis.

Talking to a few students within the campus the following day, what came up was the alleged observation by a noted politician that a body has been produced in accordance to a line supposedly exhorting the necessity for a killing, made a few days earlier in a bugged phone conversation.

Don’t think it will be an exaggeration if one is to contend that this killing may be used by several quarters to serve their political agenda. Already we have free speech supporters uniting to denounce the act plus demanding the rooting-out of fundamentalism.

However, realistically speaking, given the busy background against which the assault was carried out, one wonders how much safety can actually be offered to those who decide to be outspoken.

From another angle of the debate, we must also ask if the Bangladeshi society as a whole is ready to provide a secure ground for those who adhere to Western style “no holds barred” secularism.

Please don’t get me wrong here -- in my opinion, most people in Bangladesh are secular to a certain limit anyway. Leaving out sporadic secular tensions, which have never blown out of proportion, this is a country where people of all faiths have lived and still live on with relative calm.

And in that co-existence is the core definition of secularism as Bangladesh understands it.

Here, the notion that to preach one’s liberal values someone else’s faith (or one’s own) needs to be slated, has never had many takers.

Similarly, faith is woven into the lives of so many people that renouncing religion in public is also not something which exacts plaudits.

Then again, no one is forcing somebody to go to the mosque or the temple -- the liberalism is not overt, it’s woven within the society’s ethos.

Call it hypocrisy or double standards, the inherent philosophy that governs lives is “do what you want,” but if your affinities or associations are things that are contrary to the standard portrayal of tradition, then simply don’t beat the drums.

In most international media outlets, Avijit was identified as an atheist. Truth is, in Bangladesh, atheism has not blended with life as yet with ease. Just like the issue of pre-marital physical intimacy.

Modern-day teenagers and the young may very well know about the morning after pill from adverts, though it’s highly unlikely that the issue of sex before marriage will come up in casual conversation with parents. That means, before marriage, no girl or boy will ever go about saying in public that she or he had five to six relations in the past with physical closeness being an integral part of at least three.

In the UK, a survey, done several years ago, showed that on average, every man and woman had at least eight relations by the time they reached 45. Such surveys won’t bring out any such staggering statistics in Bangladesh, though the real picture may not be too different.

It’s gravely disconcerting that Avijit, an expatriate, had to meet such a gruesome end, but perhaps independent-minded writers/thinkers should also take into account the complex social equations in Bangladesh before making declarations of atheism and agnosticism.