Making the case

It is a constant complaint of the ruling AL that it doesn’t get a fair shake in the media, who are always drawing a false equivalency between them and the BNP, and that there is a gulf of difference between the two parties that is not sufficiently appreciated by the chattering classes.

There is more than a modicum of truth to the accusation, and certainly the AL has never unleashed a reign of terror on the civilian population of the country, as the BNP were responsible for in the run up to the January 5 election as well as over the past month and a half.

This is not to say that the AL is either perfect or faultless, only to point out that there do exist significant areas of difference between it and the BNP. For the most part, the differences (for instance, when it comes to extra-judicial killings) are more in degree than kind, but the numbers do bear them out.

Now is the time for the AL to sharpen the distinctions between it and its rivals and to show the Bangladeshi public that it really is fundamentally different from the alternative.

Indeed, the bar is so low, that even very token steps in the direction of good governance and respect for fundamental rights would go a long way towards cementing a better reputation for the party.

The recent arrest of Mahmudur Rahman Manna in fact offers the ruling party a gilt-edged opportunity to demonstrate the difference between the AL and not only the BNP but the caretaker government that ruled this country for two years from 2007 to 2008.

Custodial abuse and torture is one of the most egregious of wrongs that is routinely committed by successive Bangladeshi governments. We all know that serious abuse in police custody is business as usual, and that those unfortunate enough to be taken into custody on even the most minor of charges can expect serious physical abuse.

Those who are arrested on more serious charges of instigating political unrest are even less fortunate, and the lower you are down the totem pole, the worse the torture you can expect.

It is worth noting that as bad as things were prior to independence, the Pakistani authorities maintained some semblance of decency when incarcerating their political foes. The likes of Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and Dr. Kamal Hossain may have spent considerable time behind bars, but at least they were never tortured or abused. Sadly, in independent Bangladesh, our record has not been as good.

But custodial abuse and torture is an area where the AL does indeed have a better record than either the BNP or the various military-backed governments of the past, including the most recent one. I have heard of no parallel to the torture meted out to MK Alamgir by both the BNP and later the caretaker government, when the AL have been in power.

This is a record that the AL should be proud of and should do everything it can to uphold. There truly is a world of difference between a government that does not torture and a government that does. This is the perfect way for the party to demonstrate the distinction between it and its predecessors in office and to show the public how things can be different under an AL government.

For a party that has spent so much of its existence in opposition and that has seen so many of its stalwarts put behind bars at one time or another, the focus on respecting political rights and protecting the fundamental rights of the accused should be a comfortable fit.

Which brings us back to the case of Manna. He has long been a strident critic of the government, and as a one-time AL leader, his criticisms of the party have had more impact and done more damage than those of many others. Due to his ubiquity on television, he is among the most prominent and recognisable of the government’s critics.

The case against him is a serious one and the charges grave. He is accused of attempting to instigate the armed forces to unseat the government, possibly the most serious crime anyone could be charged with, certainly in the political scheme of things.

The country has been in crisis since the start of the year and remains balanced on a knife-edge. In such an environment, the government could be forgiven for operating with zero tolerance for those who would seek to destabilise them.

There can be little doubt what the BNP or the last caretaker government would have done to someone accused of such serious crimes against the state.

This is a chance for the AL to really show that it is different from its rivals and predecessors and that it will run the country according to the rule of law and not through fear and intimidation.

By all means, the case against Manna must be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, and no one would blame the government for the most stringent punishment if he is found guilty. But let his case stand as an example of the government’s commitment to due process, to transparency, to its respect for the rule of law and fundamental rights.

The whole nation is watching, and judicious handling of Manna’s case would do the AL more good with the general public than all the billboards, PR publications, and public service announcements extolling the government’s virtues put together.