The bigger they are ...

On January 25, Dhaka Tribune published a Reuters report from Davos, Switzerland, where leaders of the world’s business communities had met to talk about the future of the global economy. The report described the issue of splitting big banks into smaller units for regulatory purposes. Known as “too big to fail,” most of these banks were found responsible for the financial crisis that brought the world financial system to the brink of collapse in 2008.

While large banks in USA, such JP Morgan and the Citi group, have recovered their losses and paid off bailout money to the government out of their earnings, according to a study by the Boston Consulting Group “in Europe, banks have still not returned to economic profit since the financial crisis.” Banks in the US made profits because the policy-makers in USA adopted growth-supporting expansionary monetary policies and targeted the large auto sector to lead the recovery, whereas Europe followed austerity measures to bring huge public sector deficits under control.

Reuters reported: “Europe’s bankers defended the big bank model this week in Davos as the mounting cost of regulation puts a question mark over its future,”  and “big complex banks must now hold far more capital (equity) than in the past because they are seen as posing higher economic risks and they have to be easier to dismantle if they hit trouble.” They say that has held back their profitability, that is ROE, and has held back share prices.

This debate on the debt-equity for banks has been going on for a long time, banks have resisted change from their narrow perspectives of higher ROE by using very high degrees of leverage (borrowed money). For example, when Leman Brothers, a large and complex bank, collapsed in 2008, it had a debt-equity ratio of 97.5% to 2.5% only.

Serious efforts were put in the USA by establishing a high-powered commission, and a very detailed report and recommendation was prepared by two senators, named Dodd-Frank. JP Morgan’s CEO Jamie Dimon, a strong advocate of the status quo, found support from his European allies such as HSBC, Barclays, and Deutsche Bank. He termed the new rules as an assault from regulators, a position he has been maintaining since the push began in USA.

It was reported that JP Morgan was under pressure to raise $20 of extra capital in December 2014 to meet tougher US rules on big banks. So far, JPM and the Citi group paid around $16bn in penalties for illegal dealing in FX markets. It was also reported that JP Morgan’s shares were trading at 0.9 times the bank’s book value, and Citi group trade was on 0.7 times. In contrast, Wells Fargo, a mostly retail and commercial bank, trades on 1.6 times its book value.

This explains that the market puts value on the genuine banking assets, as opposed to some opaque transactions that universal and complex banks undertake. In other words, some of the big banks’ assets are toxic and are exposed to much higher risks such as their derivative assets which have little or no relation with productive activities.

Just to give an idea of the derivative assets, it was reported in a paper in The New York Times that default risk from a debt of $1.2bn of one UK retail giant faced a staggering amount of $20tn in debt-swaps, amongst hedge funds linked with such big banks. Big is not beautiful at all, as the Reuters report headlined in DT.

Banks in Bangladesh are also faced with large defaults on loans given to some privileged parties without serious analysis regarding financial violability. This is more common with state-owned banks, which are subject to more pressure from political parties. These banks are now operating with large negative equity, and the government has been putting billions of taka from the annual budget year after year.

It does not require much deeper analysis to show that such misallocation of scarce public resources are a drag on the economic development of the country. At the same time, such transfer of public money to private parties is contributing to the rising disparity in income distribution, which has already reached high proportions in the country.

A recent paper in a Bangla daily mentioned that money-laundering is also associated with such unearned money, and that a part of that money is also coming back to the country in the guise of remittance from abroad as foreign investment.

These public sector banks were made PLCs by a previous government, but no effort was made to sell their shares to the public by the present government. Perhaps this was avoided to not show the true magnitude of the loss of asset-values relative to book-values.

It is time the government dealt with these nationalised banks in a proper manner, instead of supporting them with weak financial fundamentals. These banks are also too big, and it would be advisable to break them up into regional banks if privatisation is not done within short time.