Dhaka is no Rome

The blockade of Dhaka, called by the country’s main opposition, has entered its third week, and from news reports and utterances of the opposition leader, it seems the blockade will be indefinite, or at least until the government bows down to the opposition’s demands.

I call it a blockade of Dhaka since the purpose is to isolate the capital from the rest of the country by preventing traffic to or from outside the capital city. The opposition calls this blockade successful, while the government claims the blockades have been essentially ineffective since transports to and from the city to outlying districts are operating. 

However, it is only the suffering masses who know how disingenuous both claims are. The opposition is riding on a massive campaign of anarchy and terror all over the country, while the government has deployed all forces at its command, primarily to keep the capital running. 

It seems there are two parallel forces are at work, each trying to bring the other to its knees. While the government and its law enforcement agencies are hard at work trying to keep Dhaka normal, the opposition is at work to paralyse the districts through incessant acts of random violence and to snap the link between the capital and the rest of the country. This should not have been so.

In normal countries, people expect the government to deal with lawbreakers with a firm hand. This means having a strong government, highly effective law enforcement agencies, and ensuring safety of lives and property of the citizens. However, we are not in a country working under normal conditions. 

Our law and order problems are not normal. They have been politically generated with goals that are aimed to bring down a government. Therefore, the government response has been asymmetrical. The first reaction to the opposition’s call for the blockade of Dhaka has been to tighten up the city’s security and break up the opposition’s organisation power in the capital.

Much of the law enforcement’s resources have been retained to ensure control of the capital leaving less for the rest of the country. This also gave the opposition greater opportunity to rally its troops and allies to mount their attacks in the districts under relatively less watchful eyes and resistance.

The victims of this blockade strategy and the counter-response are unfortunately ordinary people; people who have to earn a living selling goods and services, going from place to place. And these people are not confined to Dhaka alone, nor do they live in any single district. They live all over, and they need to move from one place to another. 

Trucks do not operate because they bring food and supplies to Dhaka alone, these also move supplies to other places. So when trucks, buses, and trains do not operate between Dhaka and other places, the rest of the country suffers equally. When the opposition shuts down districts with its blockades, the safety and security of Dhaka alone cannot bring safety and security to the whole country. 

Ensuring law and order for one-tenth of the population is not keeping order in the country. Rather, the country remains hostage to the looming threat of being broken up. By the same token, the opposition’s game of bringing down a government without taking the whole populace with its demand is also as fanciful.

The country seems to now be locked in a contest of two misguided strategies, where the contestants seem to be farther and farther removed from the real demand of the people, the demand to put a stop to this mad contest for power, and win the country back. 

An ancient Roman law forbade any general from crossing the Rubicon river and entering Rome proper with a standing army. To do so was treason. The law was devised to keep any ambitious governor of the Roman Empire from seizing power from the central authority. 

In Bangladesh, we do not have provinces, nor do we have a rule that anyone who controls Dhaka controls all of Bangladesh. Dhaka is neither Rome, nor Bangladesh a Roman Empire. Yet, from the strategies of two current political contestants it would appear that control of the capital is central to maintaining control over the rest of Bangladesh.

Hence this blockade, and hence this frenetic attempt to array all resources to put out all opposition in Dhaka. In this dual attempt, carnages are occurring every day in the districts because the focus of the government is on the capital alone.

We do not know if in between the contest the Rubicon will be crossed, or if there will be a victor in this contest. But we do know, however, that in modern democracies, disputes are not resolved by sword or violence, but by negotiations and discussions. 

Statesmen know how to handle crises and save their nations from disaster. Only politicians looking for personal scores seek other means to solve disputes. Our only hope is that our political contestants behave more like statesmen than run-of-the-mill politicians.