The absurdity of canine insults

With the drastic uptick in political temperature and the upsurge in confrontational politics, cyberspace – or at least the part of it still active in the “shut down all apps” mentality of the supposedly Digital Bangladesh regime – has become the arena for the verbal kind of confrontation. 

In a way it is better, I guess, to savage each other through Facebook posts and blog entries instead of using police bullets and cocktails. Yet, a dear friend of mine does take offense to something rather all too common in this raging battle of words: The proclivity to tar an opponent, real or imagined, with nefarious comparisons to dogs.

I get it, trust me I do. It is a phenomenon that has become rather uniquely South Asian these days to instinctively insult people as “kutta” and “kuttar bachcha” and more colourful derivatives thereof. Added to such colourful language is the opportunity nowadays to cut-paste cartoons and Photoshop pictures, and upload them to make the point more visually, and even viscerally.

Nonetheless, the colourfulness of the barbs or the ease of the accompanying embellishments do not make them any more accurate. In fact, nothing could be further from the truth when we think deep about it. Ask yourself, when was the last time a group of dogs got together to conspire to lock up other dogs in their kennels?

Or, for that matter, when did you last see a dog just decide to throw a firebomb at the puppies of another? In fact, the care and mutual love that wolves – in terms of DNA, the wild equivalent of the domestic dog – show each other in their packs is nothing short of exemplary. Domestic dogs’ loyalty, kindness, and self-sacrifice for their human companions is legendary, going back to the first recorded evidence of their presence in human society more than 30 millennia ago.

Even the Holy Qur’an refers to the loyalty and decency of the canine species in Surah Al-Kahf where the story is told of believers fleeing persecution and finding shelter in a cave alongside their faithful dog who kept them company and kept watch at the threshold for the evil pursuers.

Today, dogs do everything from detecting cancer, giving assistance to the blind, guarding homes and hearths, and sniffing out drugs and explosives. Many a four-legged “man’s best friend” dies every day in the noble pursuit of these exalted duties.

The only time dogs will involve themselves in gratuitous violence is to protect their families, four-legged and two-legged, from immediate physical harm. Now, tell me, can the same be said of human beings? We all know the answer to that question. There are good and evil amongst human beings; amongst dogs, the latter simply doesn’t exist.

While I write this somewhat tongue in cheek, it is not entirely without a serious perspective. See, when we reduce political rhetoric to worn out cheap shots, not much fruitful dialogue takes place. The toxicity of such predictable insults shuts down any possibility of a mature conversation about bridging divides or finding common ground. Insults, even the most shockingly counterintuitive ones, like the kind mentioned above, leave nobody the wiser intellectually and almost everyone impoverished morally.

So here is a piece of advice from my dear friend: Lose the silly insults, engage in some productive and respectful dialogue worthy of a species on the top of the food chain, and, if you must bring dogs into the picture, use the comparison accurately at least, as an example emulation of the sublime qualities of decency, loyalty, and selflessness.

Oh … about my friend … he is right here next to me but, unfortunately, a lack of opposable thumbs preclude him from penning this commentary himself. So he sends his canine best to all of you, and wishes that you treat human beings at least half as well as he does every day.