What Tarique should have said

If ever there was someone for whom the epithet “a young man with a great future behind him” fits perfectly, it is Tarique Rahman.

He had the world at his feet when he burst onto the political scene at the turn of the century. Young, personable, and presentable, he seemed to embody the promise of a new generation, and when the BNP swept to power in a landslide election victory in 2001, he looked set to take his place as the heir apparent to his mother as party chief and potential political leader of the future.

When it came to reaching out to the new generation of Bangladeshis, the BNP had the first mover advantage, and quickly were able to establish themselves as a party of the young and for the young. Tarique was the face and epicentre of this new-look BNP which came to be dominated by younger leaders and activists.

He succeeded in putting together a formidable political machine, and won the hearts of the BNP foot soldiers and local level activists, who looked to him as their leader and inspiration. If he was rumoured to be less than brilliant as an intellect, he made up for it with his organisational skills as well as his ruthlessness and mastery of realpolitik.

But then it all began to fall apart. Not only was his political dominance resented by the party stalwarts whom he made no attempt to win to his side, but his arrogance and rapacity and the corruption and criminality that he and his circle of cronies and operatives underwrote shook the nation to its core.

As much as anything else, it was fear of five more years in which he would only consolidate power until his position would be unassailable that emboldened the army to move on 1/11 and why so few Bangladeshis shed any tears over their take-over.

But there are always second acts in politics, and when he was released from prison, battered and broken from the horrendous abuse that he had suffered while incarcerated, he still had the wherewithal to reboot his political career.

It is now eight years since the BNP were last in office and memories of that period of misrule have faded, with the new generation of voters having little knowledge or understanding of what made Tarique such a reviled figure.

He has had plenty of time to reinvent himself as Tarique 2.0, and such is the nature of Bangladeshi politics that if had taken the time to rebrand himself as a more mature, more sober, more thoughtful, more judicious individual, he could have won the support not only of those BNP supporters who were sceptical about him, but also of the general public.

We are a forgiving people and have a soft spot for our prodigal sons. Just as the electorate would likely have forgiven the BNP its sins in a fair election in 2014, it most likely would welcome back a reformed and rehabilitated Tarique with open arms.

All he would need to do, in this country starved of leadership we can look up to and be inspired by, and with the manifold advantages of his face and name, would be to present himself as a changed man, an older, wiser Tarique who would listen to the counsel of others and heed public opinion.

He had a golden opportunity when the PM and her other party leaders began to castigate Ziaur Rahman. Instead of answering in kind, the statesmanlike and intelligent thing would have been for him to release a statement acknowledging his respect and honour for the Father of the Nation, and asking that the PM afford the same respect and honour to his father, a freedom fighter who had declared independence in the name of her father.

The effect would have been electrifying. It would have sent  a clear message of differentiation from the AL and put into sharp focus the characteristics that the average voter dislikes the most about the party, it’s co-option of our national history to serve the party agenda and its personal vilification of anyone seen as an opponent.

Intellectuals and commentators would be lined up around the block to laud his statesmanship and to draw a distinction between his approach and that of the PM and her party.

The AL is too committed to the path of rhetorical confrontation to be able to switch tracks now, but the BNP could easily have accomplished a graceful pirouette to the centre that would have appealed to the swing voter who dislikes the pettiness and personal nature of politics and is looking for a more reasonable and less vitriolic approach from his or her leader.

It was an opportunity missed, as indeed have been pretty much all of Tarique’s public pronouncements over the past 12 months.

People may have largely forgotten, possibly even forgiven, the BNP misrule from 2001-2006. But every time Tarique opens his mouth, he reminds people of the bad old days, and confirms the suspicion that, serious public relations efforts to the contrary notwithstanding, neither he nor his party have changed at all.