I don’t know how this originated, but since the late 70s, we have been hearing about how Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib was a great leader, but not a successful statesman. On the other hand, there are claims that Ziaur Rahman was a very good statesman.
Again, I don’t know what kind of research had been done by the country’s political scientists to back these up, but many of them told me that Zia emerged from the failures of the ruling BAKSAL.
Most of us know it was Bangabandhu and his leadership that earned this nation an independent status. A few of his party men actively took part in our war for liberation, and many of them were divided, but some of them led the temporary Bangladesh government in Kolkata.
There was always some underlying tension between the military leadership, their contingent, and the party-backed freedom fighters, but we could care less because most of our freedom fighters were not regular army men. Yet, it was their commitment and sacrifice which earned us our much vaunted freedom.
When we teach leadership in a classroom, we mention Ziaur Rahman as a situational leader. The then Major Ziaur Rahman, in 1971, was the first person to come forward to make the globally-heard announcement of our independence on behalf of our great leader Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. I am sure there were others available, but none of them took the initiative, but did possibly hop on the bandwagon afterwards.
Zia obviously took a risk – he could’ve been killed by the Pakistan army. No matter who says what, the Pakistan Eastern Command hated this major and the “Z” force commander. His colleague in the Pakistan army, Hussein Muhammad Ershad, came to East Pakistan in 1971 on vacation and went back smiling, but he had never thought of becoming a muktijoddha.
On the other hand, the contribution of Flight Lieutenant Matiur Rahman and some of his peers will remain a part of our history.
Many of my freedom fighter relatives, journalists, or even civil bureaucrats have told me that those who didn’t fight the Pakistan army or the Razakars would never fully understand what our Liberation War was all about.
Newspaper reports tell us there were around 151,000 certified freedom fighters. I don’t know how many of them had fought with arms and risked their lives, but many of them hold certificates due to their contribution to our Liberation War. However, most of the army personnel who joined the Liberation War risked their lives and took part in attacks against the Pakistan army. I know that many of those people had either joined Zia in his party, or supported him.
After Bangabandhu was brutally killed in 1975, most of his followers or colleagues had gotten disorganised, and non-committal to their party or its leadership – reports revealed how some of them even conspired against him.
While some mid-ranking army officials had joined this killing mission, none of the reports or court verdicts ever mentioned if Zia had anything to do with it. Rather, some of his peers who joined the Awami League afterwards failed miserably to give the minimum possible protection to the president of the republic.
History says that coups, counter-coups, a disorganised state of politics, and an organised state of mind are what enabled Ziaur Rahman to come forward, and it’s possible that he decided to lead this country in some sort of vacuum.
Was he prepared for it? Possibly not. He borrowed expertise from certain professionals like the late chartered accountant Jamal Uddin Ahmed, M Saifur Rahman, Jahiruddin Khan, and a few anti-AL folks.
Our political scientist friends tell us that he had wanted to put up a broader platform and create space for a larger spectrum of people to help this nation move forward. There were, of course, a few mistakes in choosing the right people.
However, global or regional political reality also put a lot of pressure on him. At times, he had to go for the “head,” not the “heart,” and therefore we saw some very good professionals and academics joining him in his nation-building campaign.
Bangabandhu was handed a war-ravaged economy, the resuscitation of which required a lot of help from the international community. I am told, for various reasons, he was unable to garner enough support from the international community.
On the other hand, Ziaur Rahman, known for his disciplined background, honest lifestyle, and composure, wanted to be in this from the beginning. Right or wrong, he could have gained support from the Middle East, Japan, or even some European and North American countries.
No matter how the political regimes try to colour them, Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujib will be remembered for giving an independent piece of land to most of the Bengali-speaking people in this part of the world, and Ziaur Rahman will be remembered for his role in our war of independence and leading this country during its transition. We then desperately needed a leader, and later, a statesman, in order to take this nation forward. But now? We possibly need more of a statesman.