To be or not to be Charlie

Let’s clear out all confusion first: Any killing as a form of revenge is utterly reprehensible. Whatever the cartoonists have done or said in the name of free speech, they didn’t deserve to be shot and killed at the beginning of a new year. But the recent slaying of Charlie Hebdo cartoonists in Paris has also opened up a hotly-debated yet never crystal clear argument about the issue of free speech.

Interestingly, there has been a rather disquieting trend within the international media to swiftly change the topic whenever there is an effort to dissect the topic of free speech, and where there should be a line asking it to make a considerate stop.

If you ask me, free speech does not mean one can just have a free run at everything at the expense of creating social havoc. Okay, I know many will counter this by saying that if so much fun can be made of other faiths like Juadism and Christianity, then why should Islam be spared? The obvious reason is that taking a humorous look at other faiths had been around for a long time, with God and paradise-related jokes finding a firm footing in almost all western cultures.

Now, that is not the case for Muslim communities. Whether it’s a country enforcing strict Sharia law or not, no Muslim majority state ever pokes fun at religion; and since I am a Bangladeshi, the best example should come from here, because the sacred place of faith is not exclusive to Islam alone.

Here in Bangladesh, religions are mostly kept outside the purview of sarcasm, facetious comments, or public ridicule. We also have progressive people here and a section within the community which is relaxed when it comes to religious do’s and don’ts.

While these liberals enjoy their beliefs and ways of looking at issues of faith, making vulgar jokes about religion never became a zealously pursued activity. Keep your convictions to yourself and let others be happy with theirs. If I am not mistaken: Live and let live is actually a Western import and not an indigenous idea.

So when it’s obvious that certain sections of a multi-cultural society are offended by something, then why try to defend it under the rather ambiguous definition of freedom of expression?

We have been deluged by the words “free speech” and “secularism” in the last few days, and this got me thinking: Multiculturalism, in my limited knowledge, means a social system where all faiths can live comfortably. So, does the pursuit of freedom of expression override the need for a harmonious existence?

Again, the avid western free speech proponent may argue that to live in a Western society, people of other faiths (meaning those representing minorities) must adhere to the ideals of that society and try to integrate. In that case, it means just ignoring the lampooning of faiths.

Just turning the other way and shrugging it off is perhaps a prudent treatment to those who want to assert their expression rights by poking fun at religion. Trust me, once people begin to disregard such callousness, the desire to play with religion will cease to be fashionable. After all, the sole purpose here is to stir the community and attract attention.

Tell me, if someone tries to disparage Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Christianity, or Judaism, will that faith become less significant? I personally feel any faith is beyond the reach of any potential harm engineered by mere mortals.

Bringing the Paris incident into perspective, one has to think about large Muslim populations residing in Western nations. The fact is, if Muslim communities want to carry on living as part of one cohesive society in a Western nation, they need to realise that no cartoon or statement for that matter can ever taint or shake the foundation of Islam. The same goes for other faiths too. Therefore, instant flaring up at the slightest provocation needs to be averted.

It reminds me of the case of the obscure American priest who wanted to burn the holy book a few years back. While this created mass hysteria among Muslims, the priest got all the media attention, which is possibly what he wanted in the first place.

The trend du jour is to say or do something to inflame the Muslims and voila, you are in the limelight. Just don’t give these instant glory-seekers the spotlight – your faith has survived many formidable challenges, so such small matters won't rock its platform. But at the same time, all this brouhaha over free speech and foaming at the mouth on the right to say whatever we want need to be discussed with plain and dispassionate logic, not paranoia.

There are plenty of things to make fun of. Why religion has to be one of them is hard to understand. The term “secular” has been spoken like an invocation by a lot of international media in the past couple of days, but my feeling is that if someone wants to find a secular society, or a community which tries to be equally respectful to all faiths, then one should come to Bangladesh and not search for it elsewhere.

Here, we do not obsessively use the term “secular,” though there is a national holiday reserved for all major religions in Bangladesh which are celebrated enthusiastically by everyone. On major Hindu occasions, like Swaraswati and Durga Puja, millions of Muslims go to witness the celebrations, with the Swaraswati Puja, especially relevant to those seeking knowledge, reaching out to students across all faiths.

The same goes for Christmas and Buddha Purnima. Yes, there are a few minor hiccups at times, but nothing that upsets the social order. Oh, I almost forgot: Major, state-sposored programs are also inaugurated by verses from the holy books of all four major religions.

Meanwhile, nations which have emphatic rhetoric on secularism don’t have state acknowledgement for religious events of “other” minor faiths. Instead of taking dogmatic stances, maybe compromising attitudes from all sides are needed in Western societies first, with freedom of expression being defined clearly.

May the cartoonists’ souls rest in peace.