Remembering Justice Morshed

January 11 marks the birth anniversary of the late Justice Syed Mahbub Murshed, who passed away in 1979. He will be remembered for many things, particularly his fearless independence on the bench and many landmark judgements, chiefly on constitutional issues.

Justice Murshed is remembered for his judgements in constitutional cases, such as the “Ministers” case, the “Pan” case and the “Basic Democracies” case. The latter two were overturned by the Supreme Court of Pakistan, but the first is perhaps best remembered and worth recalling.

Those of a certain age and inclination will remember the Ministers case in 1963 as it was about whether a cabinet minister could simultaneously be a legislator in the National Assembly. But, there was a far greater issue at stake, and that concerned the permissibility of judicial review under the 1962 constitution of Pakistan.

As the late Professor Ralph Braibanti pointed out in a paper entitled, Pakistan: Constitutional Issues in 1964, Asian Survey, 5 (2): 79-87, Article 133 of Pakistan’s 1962 constitution virtually precluded judicial review, but Murshed’s judgement in the Ministers case swept that impediment away.

And Murshed’s contribution to that success can well be argued to have been more than inconsiderable, as was what was to follow later in the Pan case regarding Centre-Province relations, and the Basic Democracies case, striking at the core of the inadequacies of the system at the time.

In the English legal tradition, until a few decades ago, there was no judicial review in any shape or form, and that country still lacks a written constitution. But there is a curious concept of “equity” in English law dating back to jurisdiction in the Court of Chancery in medieval times.

Under this principle, a dispute may be resolved by appealing to morality where there is no remedy in statute or common law. Later, we have grown to know “equity” to be based on the principles of natural law or justice. Justice Murshed applied this principle with great gusto on many occasions, such as with cases involving the requisitioning of property (particularly from religious minorities), and in the Convocation case.

There are many ways of remembering Justice Syed Mahbub Murshed, chief among which was his love of what was right, fair, and true, however inconvenient.

As John Kenneth Galbraith once stated: “To the adherents of the institutional truth there is nothing more inconvenient, nothing that so contributes to discomfort, than open, persistent articulate assertion of what is real.”