Is it too soon to start writing a political obituary for the BNP?
As little as 15 months ago, polls and local election results suggested that the party enjoyed a commanding lead over the AL in terms of popularity with the public. Even this time last year, had BNP contested the elections, it would most likely have won.
Can this kind of popularity evaporate so quickly?
Not entirely. Even today, according to the latest polling data, the BNP can command the support of perhaps some 35% of the public. Not bad for a party that has been virtually invisible for the past 12 months, is clearly utterly bereft of any ideas, and is complicit in the on-going maiming and killing of innocent civilians.
The one thing the BNP has going for it – the one thing all opposition parties have going for them in Bangladesh – is the heavy-handedness of the government. The popularity the party enjoyed through 2013 was solely a consequence of the public’s unhappiness with the incumbent government, and nothing to do with any excitement or enthusiasm it had generated of its own accord.
It is certainly possible that as the government becomes more authoritarian and less responsive to public opinion, that support for the BNP will begin to rise again, as happened in the aftermath of the 2008 elections. In fact, this is exactly what happened in the aftermath of every election we have had since 1991.
But there is reason to believe that this time it will be different.
In the first place, this is the first time that a government has had two consecutive terms in office, with all the advantages that this brings in terms of consolidation of its power and patronage and the placement of its people throughout the government machinery.
This was why the AL’s gambit in 2014 to push through its one-sided election was so crucial. By succeeding, they fundamentally altered the political reality of the country, perhaps permanently.
In the second place, it could be that the violence perpetrated by the BNP and its allies in 2013 has finally put them beyond the pale for many voters, and the BNP seems to have no game-plan beyond continuing to burn buses and bring the nation to a standstill.
But, most importantly, the BNP party machinery lies in ruins after having been systematically targeted by first the care-taker government and then the AL over the past eight years. Equally crucial, the Jamaat, which has long provided the spine of the BNP-alliance war machine, has been decimated by the combined weight of the war crimes trials and a sustained operation in the field.
It is a grim commentary on the state of our democracy when electability has more to do with how one can muster strength on the street than it has to do with how many votes you can muster at the polling booth, but there you have it.
The BNP is in shambles not because of the paucity of its ideas or indeed because of the violence of its tactics (though both those would be ample grounds), but because it has been unable to press its argument in the street.
The dismal truth is that had it been able to create more havoc, then it would be in a far stronger political position. Which in turn is why the government comes down so heavily on them in what would appear to the casual observer to be an unacceptably heavy hand.
The reality is that the government suffers no penalty for its increasing authoritarianism against the opposition or indeed against the rest of us. After all, who is going to bring them to book, if not the opposition, which it is successfully dismantling?
The government thus has absolutely zero incentive to do anything other than continue to crush the BNP under its heel. The only thing it has to fear is that the BNP will somehow survive. But there is no cost to the government for running roughshod over the nation to ensure that this does not happen.
The only thing they stand to lose is the goodwill of the general public, but since the general public will only get a chance to voice its discontents four years from now, and there is a good chance that there will be no opposition worth the name standing then, it would appear to be a sound strategy.
As an added bonus, the more they squeeze, the more atrocities the BNP will commit. This will in turn continue to harm their popularity and give the government further grounds to crack down even harder (on the rest of us as well). It’s a winning strategy for the AL.
The BNP is not finished. No party that can continue to attract upwards of one voter in three can be entirely written off as a spent force. But without a dramatic change – that seems increasingly unlikely under the present leadership – it is hard to see how they come back from here.