The mother-son debacle

I did not plan to write on this, but I am now forced to, after seeing such a political debacle made by a major leader, her party, and her son.

Opposition BNP Chairperson Begum Khaleda Zia got angry since she failed to pull enough support to organise a rally on January 5, marking year one of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina’s first year of her third tenure in office, as no such supporters were there to overcome a police restriction on rallies and demonstrations. It was not only the police’s decision to not allow her to go to Nayapaltan.

She refused to go home from her Gulshan office. The government has its reasons too, by citing security concerns for “restricting” her movement. However, one must remember that providing security to Begum Zia, or any other citizen, is a government duty, and all steps were taken based on intelligence reports.

One report that I gathered said that intelligence had sufficient proof that if the rally was allowed to be held, then at the end of it, Jamaat and its student-wing Islami Chhatra Shibir would have created chaos like what Hefazat had tried to instigate sometime ago. Which government would ever allow something like that to be repeated? What citizen would like to see such violence and arson be perpetrated?

So the term “confined” for Begum Zia, in this context, is incorrect. The right word should have been “restricted,” as she was told repeatedly that she could go home, but not to her central office in the downtown Nayapaltan area. I say this as a journalist, because, from the first minute I had disagreed with the use of this word – which was eagerly gobbled up and widely-used by the media without even thinking if it was right or wrong.

The moment Chittagong police allowed BNP to hold its rally, the intelligence report came true – just when the Jamaat-Shibir, BNP’s best friends, joined up and unleashed terror, in which BNP leaders suffered too. Thus the government’s decision cannot be slammed just because Begum Zia felt sad when her plans fell apart.

Then came her time to “go to downtown Dhaka at any cost” in her SUV. As was predicted, the vehicle stopped at the gates, and she gave a statement with no concrete message to the populace, except the message to join her campaign against the government. Why should the people join her anti-government campaign? Just because she missed the election bus in 2014 due to a major tactical mistake?

Then came disaster. She ended her statement to the press and to the people courtesy of private TV channels. Two reporters, one of whom was a Chhatra Dal activist in his student life, kept pushing her, asking what her new campaign plan was. She did not have any. She did say that the blockade would continue. I was wondering, was a blockade already in force? If so, who was it called by?

Then comes the question: If the time was ripe for a non-stop blockade – was there public support for violence instead of peaceful politics by Sheikh Hasina? Hours later, when confusion reigned about the blockade within the 20-party alliance and also among the populace, Begum Zia’s press secretary had to explain how the blockade would be carried out.

Then the blockade actually started, and I call it a Jamaat-Shibir-enforced and Khaleda Zia-called blockade. It was mainly the Shibir which went on a rampage in various places, resulting in the deaths of several people. Who will take responsibility for that?

Let us come to BNP – its leadership has failed to aide or guide Begum Zia at such a crucial hour, but I guess her elder son Tarique Rahman was guiding her from London via telephone. He could also be seen online, delivering a speech as hollow and silly as a speech could be.

When I listened to parts of it, I thought to myself: “He was far away from reality and living in a fool’s paradise, while his speech was tantamount to inciting political violence and unrest within disciplined armed forces.”

Tarique Rahman was saying that the movement has started, and nobody should leave the streets. Who are these bodies? They are the handful of Jamaat-Sihbir activists and a few men from his own party. Would that topple an elected civilian government? It seems to me that he was thinking it was a situation much like the last days in the reign of former president Hussein Muhammad Ershad in 1990.

I had covered the anti-Ershad movement and had interviewed Begum Zia and Sheikh Hasina on the streets of Dhaka for AFP.

Then came Awami League’s campaign for a caretaker government, which fostered huge popular support. Then why is Begum Zia’s call for a similar government being ignored?

The reason is quite clear – as I had said earlier. Begum Zia killed the concept at the end of her last term in office by appointing Iajuddin Ahmed as chief advisor before it was overturned by the 1/11 developments. The other reason is that the electorate has had enough experiments for some to go to power, and the other to stay in power, and have now opted for peace and life without terror threats, as was the situation during the BNP-Jamaat rule.

As political blogger Jyoti Rahman’s wrote in this newspaper: “As things stand, with Tarique Rahman in his current avatar as BNP’s chosen future, I am afraid the future is bleak, and we might soon be discussing BNP’s past.”

The whole episode has been a debacle for Begum Khaleda Zia and her son Tarique Rahman, and they now have to ask themselves how long they can sustain a four-year plus blockade in Bangladesh, when life almost returned to normal on the third day.