Taking stock

December 31 is a banking holiday. Though there are no customer transactions, the mainframe system is busy calculating profits and losses for the entire year.

Some commercial bank managers even take this time to arrange luncheons or exchange greetings by distributing sweets to their larger clients. Most are talking about how the year went, though. I am sure Thursday or Friday’s newspapers will carry a lot of news on this.

Banking in Bangladesh, or more broadly the financial sector, has become quite a failed case for the ruling regime. Large loan scams, weak security and collateral, diversion of funds to real estate, capital market, or even overseas, low profitability, poor internal control, weak risk management, continuous interference from the owners, and poor management standards have become synonyms for Bangladeshi banking.

Not even the Ministry of Finance or Bangladesh Bank could do much in this regard. The Finance Ministry could not make sure they were in command for the government’s undertakings.

Often, interference from the highest office, political intervention in selection of the state-owned bank chairman, director, or even managing director expedited the “nowhere to go” situation for them.

Everyone has witnessed the continuous tug of war between the ministry, a few stalwarts in the highest office, some influential ministers, or even ruling party biggies and the watchdog agency. At times, the somewhat achieved independence of the watchdog agency has been questioned due to too much political pressure.

Some people at the central bank have really worked hard, but they were to approve the day-to-day transactions of business entities, not much could be done to further streamline the policy regime.

Thanks to the central bank’s continuous focus and the commitment of its operators, agriculture finance, mobile commerce, or even school banking have made very good progress.

Our country has seen phenomenal growth in mobile banking transactions. Focus had also been given on e-commerce and the redefinition of CSR activities in banks.

It was good, more so in view of all nine new banks being given licenses on political considerations, and most of their owners being very eager to expand branch presence to their native places and grant CSR allocation to their near and dear ones. The central bank has reports that too much of CSR funds were being diverted to sports, or for the owners’ domain buildings.

Bangladesh Bank’s efforts to ensure a shift to quality assets in banks have been put to question with the issuance and exercise of a new loan rescheduling circular, issued in view of protecting the victims of the political meltdown which was seen at the end of 2013.

It could reportedly take care of a few old or perennial defaulters, or large, politically favoured business houses only. There are instances of politically appointed state-owned bank chairmen requesting the chairman of a private commercial bank for undue rescheduling of large business house loans.

According to reports, Bangladesh Bank is not too happy with the classified loan situation in the commercial banks. It is around 11.6% of the country’s total Tk4.94tn banking sector funded assets.

But accountants, and people with above average visibility, tell us if we apply more qualitative judgment, this figure would easily cross 20% of the banking sector loan.

A lot of money has been flown into companies with weak internal cash flow generation, poor fundamentals, weak business plans, or those who can’t withstand competition or face any industry consolidation. Large commodity loans in Chittagong faced the music in view of the global price reduction of commodities or had lost out to competition with better access to lower interest rates or control on easy bank financing.

A lot of large private commercial banks got caught up in debacles with management changes or for sticking to a few cronies who are otherwise not good bankers. Finding out good senior banking resources is increasingly becoming a tough job.

On the other side, we have not seen banks spending much in organisational development. Most of them were shy in allocating much for building alternate banking solutions, building robust IT infrastructures, or retail banking solutions.

They were not happy with large classified loans, but did very little to avoid their reoccurrance in the future. Higher profit targets, less time to analyse the underlying or ultimate risk or recovery, or even the restructuring of distressed assets put the banks in further risk. Most of the banks’ seniors are not sure what they should be doing more of or doing less of.

Day-to-day witch-hunting is not allowing them to dedicate some quality time towards developing new business models, improving risk architecture, or developing core resources.

Going forward, the central bank should be seen allocating more of its time in reforming the existing archaic policy regime, focus more on quality shift in the banking sector, and improving the risk preparedness of the commercial banks in view of BASEL-III commandments.

Commercial banks, take them or leave them, must demonstrate their preparedness against emerging anti-money laundering (AML) risks, capital adequacy in view of deteriorating quality of assets, leadership development, IT governance, and the overhauling of the entire risk management system – the way we analyse risk, address risk, administer risk, monitor risk, and ensure damage control.