The system is broken

Perhaps we are looking at this all the wrong way, and we should instead view the farcical one-sided election of January 5 as an opportunity rather than as a travesty.

Don’t get me wrong. I am on record as opposing the January 5 elections, and the bait and switch exercised by the government through which it looks as if they fully intend to serve out their five year term, in blithe contradiction of their pre-election promise, only makes things worse.

The thing is, though, that while I do not believe that the January elections were representative or give the government a mandate to rule for five years, nor do I believe that a fully representative election would necessarily have solved anything.

To my mind, the political system that has served us at best serviceably over the past two decades has finally broken down and is beyond repair. While bad elections are obviously no solution, for the first time since the restoration of democracy two decades ago, I am not sure that good elections would have resolved much, either.

The simple truth is that the current system we have in place is incapable of delivering to us a workable political solution that is competent to address the needs of the country.

Our single constituency, first-past-the-post electoral system, that delivers all power to the winner, fails to keep any kind of a check and balance on our elected representatives, and cannot ensure any kind of separation of powers so that independent branches of the government can actually operate independently, has reached the limits of what it can deliver.

It hasn’t been all bad. The last two decades have seen a reasonable rise in prosperity and drop in poverty. Education and health have shown gains. There has been a modicum of stability. But this is as good as it gets.

But look around you. Can anyone really suggest that we have taken the kind of steps necessary that we need to ensure sustained growth and development, or that we have been able to put in place, let alone implement, any kind of a vision that would make the country a qualitatively better place to live in the years to come?

Part of the problem is surely our political system. There are so many obvious reforms that would help deliver better governance, but under the current system no elected government has either the inclination or the incentive to do so.

Why would a legitimately elected government with a mandate to rule for five years be even remotely interested in passing legislation to curtail its own powers or to create a more workable system?

The last caretaker government did in fact attempt some piecemeal reforms, but having neither the legitimacy nor the authority to really do so, it shied away from the big ticket items which might have made a real difference and which in any case would have likely been overturned as soon as an elected government returned to office.

The current government occupies a curious middle-ground. Unlike the last elected government, it has no real mandate to run the country for the next five years nor can it really claim to be a fully representative government of the people.

However, unlike the caretaker government, it does have constitutional authority and full legitimacy to enact far-reaching legislation that would be in the nation’s long-term interest.

And, not having come to office on the back of popular support, and not knowing how long the public would continue to support its tenure, it has every incentive to start a national conversation on constitutional reform.

One possible solution to the current crisis would be to move towards fully participatory elections as soon as possible, and I would certainly prefer that to five years of the current government, with its questionable mandate and moral legitimacy.

But maybe we can do better than that. Maybe we can see this government as a kind of instrumentality and use its tenure in office as a kind of interregnum period during which we retool the entire political system into something fairer and more workable, and which will deliver better governance to the people.

Let’s put it all on the table, from proportional representation to a presidential system of government to a federal system to truly empowered local government to true separation of powers to term limits to a bicameral legislature to reforms to give the opposition more power. The list is endless.

Let’s accept that we have come as far as the current system can take us, and that to build on the gains of the past two decades of parliamentary democracy and to ensure that we do not move backwards, that we need to all sit down in good faith and work together for a political solution that will not only last for decades to come but will deliver us to where we want to go as a nation.

The political parties should forget about winning the battle for the next five years. The conversation shouldn’t be about how to have elections as soon as possible or how to remain in power for the next five years.

The conversation should be how to enact far-reaching and long-lasting reform that will ensure that we can finally move beyond the dysfunctions that have dogged our politics and governance since at least 2001.

That would be a conversation which would be in the better long-term interests of both main political parties than the one that we have been having for the past year.

More to the point, it would be in the better long-term interest of the Bangladeshi people, too.