In 2001, the Asian Development Bank funded a million dollar study on oil spill contingency planning for Bangladesh (TA 3357). The study, led by Japan Oil Engineering, had several components, among which the effects on mangroves in the Sundarbans Reserve Forest (SRF) of a potential oil spill in the Pussur River was analysed scientifically by national and international experts.
The TA was developed against the backdrop of the growing threat of environmental degradation at the two major ports of Bangladesh. Oil spills represented a threat to general port operations, particularly at Chittagong port, which had the only oil refinery in the country. Direct oil spill risks at Bangladesh’s second port, Mongla port, while less than at Chittagong, owing to the lower oil transport volumes and absence of an oil refinery, were nonetheless significant for environmental reasons.
Mongla port is located 3km north of the SRF, which has been declared a World Heritage Site. Mongla is reached mainly through a 100km-long navigational channel that runs through the SRF. Without proper management, monitoring, and risk assessment, the movement of oil and chemical products through the SRF represented a potential major threat to the area.
The extensive mangrove areas of the Sundarbans are highly sensitive to pollutants. Among those, oil pollution does not only mean an immediate destruction of a large number of species and the destruction of the habitat, but also that deterioration of the mangroves may also lead to major changes in sediment transport and erosion, thus changing navigational conditions and reducing the chances of rehabilitation of the area.
The study was designed to take a two-tiered approach to the environmental problems at the two ports. First, at a policy level, it developed the basis of a national oil spill contingency plan that would provide the legal, regulatory, and operational frameworks for oil spill response mechanisms for Mongla and Chittagong ports. The study prepared manuals on port environmental management, forest oil spill impact assessment and monitoring, oil spill response training, as well as providing fellowships in field operations.
The program also included a two-week study tour and intensive training in Singapore by the Singapore Ports Authority and East Asia Response Private Limited (EARL), an internationally reputed institution with IMO Levels 2 and 3 facilities.
Second, on a biodiversity conservation plane, the program analysed the risk of contamination of areas within the SRF which are sensitive to pollution caused by oil spills, with papers on water quality and sensitivity maps, species diversity, and impact on mangroves. The Sundarbans is one of the most valuable and irreplaceable ecosystems in the globe.
The program emphasised how it was critical that Bangladesh recognised the seriousness of the situation in the Sundarbans and initiate early responses to that potentially significant environmental threat.
Of the prominent and important tree species found in the Sundarbans (Sundari, Gewa, Baen, Keora, Kankra, Passur, Golpatta), Sundari is most vulnerable to oil spills. The most potentially heavily-affected areas appeared to be such places as the Sundari-dominant areas, lower ground level, gentle inclined shore, inner fringe and basin, mud flat, and direct contact points to the landed oils. From the avifaunal and biodiversity points of view, the pollution of sand bar and mud flat were equally significant.
The study noted that, in the event of an oil spill, selecting the clean-up and rehabilitation areas on a priority basis according to environmental sensitivity maps should be taken into full consideration in advance. Natural flushing could be expected along the river banks and erosion-prone steep shores, so mechanical cleaning was of minimum necessity there.
On the other hand, virtually inaccessible forests of inner fringe and/or inner basin might have difficulties in heavy clean-up operations, so that it would be unrealistic to save many trees. Clean-up activities, then, should be concentrated on the relatively easy places to handle, for example muddy and sandy flats or outer fringe forests, with the permanent presence of Department of Forestry staff and continued observation and monitoring.
The study emphasised that it was of prime importance to respond to an oil spill incident immediately on-site. Every effort possible should be made to contain and recover the spilled oil and not to let it stand. As the deployment of booms or skimmers might be delayed and have little effect, particularly in the monsoon season, the use of dispersants could be a viable option, but those dispersants would only work under certain, limited circumstances.
As oils such as diesel and petrol disperse naturally, within the shortest periods, most attention should be given to tackling heavy fuels. The study recommended more field tests to clarify the effect and toxicity of dispersants to the SRF mangrove ecosystems and the most effective, least toxic, dispersant is to be screened for future use.
The study noted that improvised booms could be made from readily available materials, such as bamboos, logs, gunny bags, raw jute, rags, and straw bales, to collect the floating oils on the water surface. Involvement of locals in combating the oil spills, if possible, was highly recommended from the viewpoint of more cost-effective operation.
At a workshop on the results of the study on September 25, 2001, the then minister of agriculture, shipping, and fisheries had observed that the “lack of a monitoring and regulatory framework for the movement of oil and chemical products … is a significant threat to the SRF.” The government had promised to do all it could to protect the SRF.
It is a pity that, despite the study, detailed recommendations, and intensive training, nothing substantive was done to institutionalise those recommendations. Would we have been fully prepared for what happened a few days ago? Perhaps not entirely, but at least the problem would have been recognised formally with the creation of technical and community response teams, and international support mechanisms.
Nonetheless, much of the material could be useful in developing current response mechanisms. A lesson learned is that, unless there is prompt and timely responsiveness, the costs of inaction can be enormous, with potentially irreversible impacts.