Can we put a price on the Sundarbans?

There is a possibility that our authorities’ singular failure to show any form of urgency in averting the aftermath of the oil spill in the Sundarbans recently, owes a great deal to the difficulty of capturing the disaster’s monetary value. How much will it cost us?

This plays into the recent trend of everything being standardised in terms of its worth in taka or dollars, and the difficulty of monetising our natural resources, unless they are converted into a form that lends itself to commercial valuation, is part of the reason why it took the world so long to wake up to the reality of climate change.

Biodiversity, unique ecology – all of these terms associated with the Sundarbans resist easy valuation. But that should hardly be an excuse for undervaluing them. The innumerable benefits of the Sundarbans range from from mitigating the effects of a cyclone like Sidr to its potential for being developed as a tourist hotspot. If anything, that alone should tell us that it is, in a word, invaluable.

Yet, it is sad but true that, as disastrous as the oil spill of December 9 has been, what probably bodes far worse for the future of the world’s largest mangrove forest is the callous attitude displayed by the administration towards mitigating the ill-effects and ensuring that something like this never happens again. Some 350,000 litres of oil can sound a lot worse than it is in reality.

But truly, you would be hard-pressed to find a representative of any government in any country around the world, who sounds worse than Shipping Minister Shahjahan Khan did last week, in his callous pronouncements about a source of such pride and joy for the nation.

For his benefit, let me be clear: This is the worst man-made disaster the Sundarbans has ever experienced. The Sundarbans is not only the last stronghold of Bangladesh’s tiger and spotted deer populations, it is home to our saltwater crocodiles, the globally threatened masked finfoot, and the largest population of Irrawaddy dolphins in the world.

On top of all this, about 10 million people’s livelihoods depend on the Sundarbans. So it is preposterous to pretend as if this is merely an environmental issue. It is every bit a human issue.

Having said that, we must wean ourselves off an attitude where whenever something goes wrong, we blame the government. As a nation, are we aware of our own responsibilities? Are we prepared to make the sacrifices needed, in order for Bangladesh to shine amongst other nations?

This train of thought is occasioned by the fact that the capsised vessel was carrying furnace oil, to be supplied to a power plant project near Gopalganj. Although the Shela river is meant to be off-limits to vessels carrying supplies such as furnace oil, the closing down of the usual route from Khulna to Gopalganj, due to massive siltation, has caused the authorities to permit this in the last three years.

The smirk the shipping minister has allowed himself all week probably owes to his knowledge of his fellow countrymen’s hunger for electricity, and the amount of investment in the sector. But the Sundarbans’ value is incalculable. A statement like that is often hyperbolic, but in this case, it is not. The sooner the authorities, and indeed all stakeholders, realise that, the better.  

It isn’t just a matter of the odd commercial vessel capsising, of which this latest one was the third this year. Just in general as well, the forest has suffered from a history of neglect.

I understand that in Nepal, their armed forces are helping conserve wildlife in their protected areas. Our Sundarbans are ruled by pirates and poachers. We need to protect the Sundarbans, and the whole nation is left looking at the prime minister now to take the lead and show that we are earnest about doing that.

The surest way may well be to declare the forest a safe zone, and put it under the defence ministry that is usually looked after by the premier. It may sound a bit drastic, but as events over the last week have shown, in our efforts to conserve the Sundarbans, we are falling far short of what is necessary.