Burning that fuel

In view of the sliding fuel price in international markets, people have started to talk about adjusting the fuel price in Bangladesh too. Seniors in the government are thinking of what would happen to the accumulated loss of the Bangladesh Petroleum Corporation (BPC), or the huge fuel subsidy being provided in this sector.

My friends are of the opinion that common people should not be made scapegoats for the continuous losses of BPC, while some believe that the government itself doesn’t want to fix BPC and improve its performance.

Apart from sacking some of its senior officials, due to their failure in timely fuel imports or supply chain management, government actions did nothing to stop the erosion of BPC’s balance sheet, or bring in the minimum possible efficiency or accountability into BPC management.

There has been no real study into what is happening inside BPC. Is the international price rise the only culprit for continuous losses? Did shifting its head office to Chittagong help BPC better manage its business? How about reorganising BPC’s fare with people of better visibility about energy import, price, and distribution channel management? Do we have the right people managing our largest SOE?

I know the answers will be irresponsible, attributing too much to the political seniors or age-old bureaucratic norms. Then what do we need to do to fix BPC?

Fuel price in the recent past was the lowest in Bangladesh, compared to that in neighbouring countries like India and Pakistan. This price differential with India has bled us in three ways: First, a substantial quantity of fuel was being smuggled out of the country; second, the subsidy on the smuggled fuel was being enjoyed by the nationals on the other side of the border instead of our people; and third, the propensity of smuggling was creating an artificial crisis of fuel in the bordering areas.

So, apart from recovery of product cost, price adjustment was also needed to stop the smuggling. There were always questions on how this adjustment would be done with the dip and rise of fuel price in the international market, or how the impact would be allocated among different types of fuel (octane vs diesel or kerosene) or even different interest groups.

The price of fuel in Bangladesh should be aligned with international price movements on a fully-loaded basis, ie with import costs and duty included. Now that fuel price is sliding in the international market, our government, like India, should first immediately withdraw all fuel subsidies. The price of fuel, henceforth, should only be aligned with the international import price. Any subsidies to the disadvantaged group should be managed on a distribution efficiency basis.

BPC is suffering from a serious financial sickness, its bargaining power is jeopardised and thus we are desperate to procure fuel on deferred payment. Are there any analyses into the financial advantage of opening LC on a sight payment basis or deferred payment? Are the suppliers taking advantage of BPC’s bargaining capacity?

Common sense dictates that the BPC can’t bargain very well. How about issuance of a BPC bond then? It may warrant some financial discipline to be introduced to the corporation, definitely some extra work for its board and senior officials, but it will ultimately help BPC better manage its balance sheet.

Why can’t the BPC go for hedging against the fuel price fluctuation? The answers I received from many seniors in the energy ministry is that, if the price goes up, they won’t be credited, and if the price goes down, their integrity would be compromised. It’s possible we need a decision and guideline on commodity hedging soon.

BPC and Oil Marketing Companies (OMCs) allow some systematic losses of fuel in its handling and transporting at different stages. Reducing these allowable losses may reduce product cost. For example, tighter monitoring might help in reducing loss from temperature differential. Also, a more prudent and stricter approach may reduce pilferage during transportation.

A backbone pipeline between the main installation at Chittagong and the main depots at Dhaka, Khulna, and Rajshahi may help reduce transportation costs as well as pilferage. Also, it will help in reducing lead-time, which in turn will contribute in saving interest cost. Though there were discussions held earlier for making the pipeline, it was killed at its embryonic stage.

Economic decisions should rule over other considerations. If local refining is more economic, then we should increase the refining capacity and modernise the existing one.

The authorities could welcome foreign investment or joint venture partnerships in this space. Bangladesh’s built-in capacity could also be utilised for refining and exporting refined fuel to other Asian countries via Middle Eastern fuel-producing companies.

It is no surprise that BPC possesses an inherent inefficiency like many other public sector corporations. Costs may be saved through the shedding of inefficient manpower, curbing dominance of corruption, etc.

It is time to broaden the base of BPC’s board by including professionals and instilling a performance-based remuneration culture. The government should think of shifting the BPC headquarters back to Dhaka to make it more efficient. The board, once reorganised, should also be empowered further into making decisions and bypassing unnecessary interference from the ministry. It should also work more closely with finance and law ministries, two vital compatriots for the survival of BPC.