We should not lose sight of the future

When we get older, we cherish history and dwell on the past. When we are young, it is all about the future and possibilities. 

I visited Bangladesh for the first time in 2005. Ever since, I have been intrigued by its people, its culture, and especially its politics. I have been struck by the enthusiasm, dedication, and sacrifice young people have for politics and political activism. It is rare and prizeworthy. However, contrary to our normal thinking about young activists as challengers of the established order, their politics is very much circumscribed by political parties and party vocabulary and practices.

It is a reactive form of politics, which encompasses the entire society and defines and negates new forms of politics and political vocabularies. This is, of course, about history and how to define and determine the past. For any state and nation in transition, it is imperative to know and at least agree on some framework of the past, but today, I believe you are the victims of history. Let me explain.

The most important feature of this victimhood is what I will call the Iconomic configuration of the political. Iconomic is a combination of icon and economy. Rounaq Jahan has earlier described Bangladesh politics via the concept of the sarkar and sarkari parties and leadership.

This understanding of the political order is at the core of the Iconomic, but I think her concept understates the flows of resources – rewards, benefits, and favours – within the political and the political structures. Academics and commentators agree that these flows have gained importance and effect since liberation, and especially from the time when democracy was reinstated in 1991.

Nonetheless, money talks. The key feature of how this victimhood of history works is the political vocabulary. Each and every notion in politics always refers back to defining moments in history. The main source of these moments is the war of liberation and the roles and deeds of founding political figures. It is a forceful vocabulary and battlefield of historic definitions. People struggle and kill over these issues and young people are mobilised on, and for, these struggles. 

It is a vocabulary represented and materialised in political icons. These icons do not just use history to rule the country, political structures, and followers, but actively draws upon specific moments to (re)create history in and through their discourse and vocabulary. 

It is a vocabulary that organises the entire society into two competing groups, based in a dichotomy of secularism and religion, where the prize is absolute parliamentary power and control of state and state resources. And there is no escape. It is rule by law, not rule of law.

This is the economy. For followers and voters, it is about survival, livelihood, and wealth – in other words, securing a future. But for the icons that define the structures in which the resources flow, it is about determining the past and staying in the retrospective. This is where they get their legitimacy as political leaders and icons. The future might require new thinking, outlook, and perspective.

Every nation needs to shape a shared history to build a future. This is why we have seen an increase in truth and reconciliation processes, courts, and commissions around the world, in countries that have gone through violent transformations. It is processes that are similar to the current in Bangladesh, but often less vindictive and more focused on getting to the truth of the matter, or at least creating a shared understanding of why it happened, and who was responsible.

Many truth and reconciliation processes have incorporated writings of history as integral parts of the process, for example, through victim accounts, perpetrators’ statements, and archival work. In your process, death is a certainty, and history is carved in stone.

Though this process is important for the nation, we should not lose sight of the future. One could argue that there can be no future before this process is ended, the past is settled, and history is written. Yet, I would caution waiting for its finalisation.

If one takes a look at the young political activists within and outside the political parties, they are all preoccupied by the past. Often they work on slogans of a distant past, which they might feel in spirit, but they hardly know in practice.

For instance, the student organisations associated with the major political parties often refer to a glorious past of student dedication to language and nation. But their own practices are more like hooligans and gangsters, illustrated by the recent events at the universities across the nation.

The Shahbagh movement’s demand for death and their ability to change court rulings testifies to the power of the past in vocabulary, and as a mechanism of mobilisation. Yet, what was striking about the movement was the simplicity of demands, and the problem to maintain popular momentum when they succeeded. As a retrospective movement, it ended when the lack of a prospective vocabulary became apparent.

The challenge in Bangladesh is not political engagement and activism, as it is in many developed countries, but how this dedication and commitment can be transformed into something new, to offer something new, to see the world differently.

All established politicians, especially when in government, talk about an economic system of growth in GDP terms and export rates, based on a fetishism of becoming a middle income country. As if, this automatically and significantly will change the inequality. The same system, when it collapsed, had devastating effects on the poor, and negatively affected the developing countries. 

In a setting where most politicians are amongst the rich and powerful (80% are businessmen) and the political youth are linked to the parties in different ways, where can ideas of a future beyond the vocabulary of the liberation war emerge? The current political leadership, or their followers?

Student youth have played essential roles in the creation of Bangladesh as an independent nation, and have always been at the frontline to defend state and democracy. Today, youth are the majority of the population. What are their perspectives of the future, and how are they represented in politics? 

The challenge is not to convict war criminals at trials; the challenge is to think what comes after. One could wait until the processes are completed, which could take some years, or begin to prepare for a future, in the present.