Recently, during a discussion on war crimes trials and the subsequent hartals, some of my colleagues urged for more capital punishment, therefore more hartals, and more holidays. They were not concerned about who was given a death sentence, or why. Their main concern was enjoying a holiday!
Similarly, there are people who are careless about the casualties of fire outbreaks in garment factories, road accidents, hartals, and so on, which routinely claim hundreds of lives in Bangladesh. Does their conscience not bother them when faced with such human deaths?
While seeking for the answer, I recalled the term “collective unconscious,” coined by Swiss psychiatrist Carl Jung. He defined collective unconscious as the innate disposition to experience. It represents basic human behaviour and situations. To him, it “belongs to the class of ideas that people at first find strange, but soon come to possess and use as familiar conceptions.”
How did this originate? Jung asserts: “It seems to me that their origins can only be explained from assuming them to be deposits of the constantly repeated experiences of humanity. One of the commonest, and at the same time most impressive experiences, is the apparent movement of the sun every day.”
In line with Jung’s theory, I observe that we Bangladeshis, in our collective unconscious, are getting nonchalant to the events happening around us. Gradually, the sense of humanity is decaying from our national imagination. We are becoming narrowly self-centred; we don’t hesitate to gratify our desires, even by means of the life of a fellow human being.
Why is this national transformation happening? The repeated incidences of atrocity, persecution, and other catastrophic events appear shocking to us initially, but gradually become banal. We see everything, but remain motionless, collectively unconscious.
It has two major appalling consequences on our social landscape. First, the culture of protest against oppressions is diminishing, and therefore the number of persecutions is alarmingly rising. For example, hundreds have died in political violence last year, but many people don’t feel outraged because they were “political activists.”
But, in reality, they were real people with real connections, and their deaths were felt, and had impacts on certain people. We have noticed indignation among people initially when a college student, Limon, was maimed by RAB, or when journalists Sagar and Runi were brutality killed. But that did not persist for long. After these incidents, so many other killings, disappearances, and mass deaths took place, but people were silent.
Nevertheless, in the history of Bangladesh, particularly since 1947, we have noticed the culture of immense protests to safeguard humanity, and to preserve our rights. How many people were killed in 1952 or 1991? Was the death toll more than that of 2013? No, but today, we are silent and “unconscious” to the deaths.
Children subconsciously legitimise these immoral practices and gradually adopt them as their cultural belongings. In this respect, I remember an experience of philosopher Tariq Ramadan, which he has shared in a lecture recently.
He narrated that while teaching in a secondary school in Geneva, he had a student who loved conflict, and expressed his feelings through violence. Once Ramadan was called from his house and on his arrival, Ramadan found that the student brutally beat his mother.
He was shocked, and when searched for the reason behind this, he discovered that beatings were a common practice in that student’s family. The student’s father would often beat them. Ramadan explained that frequent experiences of violence made his student’s actions justified to him, and therefore he found beating his mother natural.
I fear that frequent incidents of violence and persecution might establish them as a justified means for children in Bangladesh. They might regard violence as morally legitimate. The day might not be far when a child would say after killing another: “I have done nothing wrong!”
Therefore, to escape the situation, we have to develop a culture of empathy. We have to develop the art of compassion in our national imagination. In Buddhist tradition, it is maintained that compassion starts from the self. We ourselves have to generate compassion, and teach our children to do the same.