Punished unto death?

The incident of Panir, a seventh-grader at Jurain Hazera High School, who was hospitalised after the head teacher punished him by making him do 500 squats, is utterly deplorable.

But what is really obnoxious is the comment made by the head teacher, one Alfaj Hussain, who told Panir’s father that he should come to him for an explanation to his actions only if his son died from the punishment he had received. A teacher expecting a guardian to approach him in the event of a student’s death stemming from corporal punishment can by no means be considered rational.

Panir said he, along with some of his friends, had ridiculed their classmate Shahin. Shahin complained to his uncle. When Shahin’s uncle complained against Panir and his friends Nahid and Arif, the next day, Alfaj punished them with his bare hands, after which he asked the three to do 500 squats.

Alfaj, on the other hand, gave a different account, saying the boys had teased a female student of the school and her brother, along with some friends, who came to beat them up in retaliation. He said he had to punish the boys to dissuade the girl’s brother and his friends from beating them up.

The statements are contradictory. There has been no investigation into who’s telling the truth and who’s lying. Nevertheless, there are several factors here that need to be mulled over.

To begin with, the head teacher should have been far more sensitive while handling the affair. If we consider Panir’s statement to be true, then a student ridiculing his peer is certainly not a serious offence. Shahin, the student who was ridiculed, acted quite maturely by complaining about Panir to his uncle. He could have gotten into a quarrel or even a scuffle with Panir at school, and things could have gotten much worse, but he sought the intervention of a guardian instead.

Not all seventh-graders will be offended by what Panir did in the classroom. On the other hand, Shahin cannot be blamed for taking his friends’ remarks seriously either, seeing as how one handles mockery from peers varies considerably from individual to individual. Clearly, the incident involved more psychological and social issues than academic ones, and hence should have been dealt with accordingly. There is no doubt that Alfaj failed to do so.

Another interesting aspect here is Alfaj’s account of the incident: He also said he had punished Panir and his friends after he saw the girl’s brother and two of his friends looking for the seventh-graders to beat them up.

Even if it is true, one needs to ask how humorous can the head teacher of a school get. What convinced him to think that he could save three students of his school from getting beaten up by hitting them himself and making them do 500 squats afterwards? Which official rule or law did he follow while taking action to “save” Panir and his friends?

Alfaj said the girl’s brother, whom he identified as Bashar (Panir said Bashar was Shahin’s uncle), and his friends could not be stopped from entering the school when they came to beat the three seventh-graders because they were former students of the institution. If this is something that the head teacher thinks is justified, then it needs to be seriously looked into if such an act is permitted by our country’s legal system.

Then comes the issue of the prevalence and the severity of corporal punishment in schools. If not all, the majority of our educational institutions, especially primary and secondary schools, dole out corporal punishment.

According to a judgement made on January 13, 2011, the High Court Divisional bench, comprising Justice Md Imman Ali and Justice Md Sheikh Hasan Arif, said corporal punishment constituted a clear violation of children’s fundamental rights to life, liberty, and freedom from cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment.

In the wake of the judgement, the Education Ministry directed district education officers and upazila education officers to stop corporal punishment involving infliction of physical pain. It also ordered that effective measures be taken against this practice.

However, the subsequent incidents of corporal punishment, including the case of Panir and his friends, lucidly illustrate how schools have measurably failed to comply with the court order. Teachers have also shown flagrant disregard for a legal ruling by acting against what the court said.

Although the court issued a directive to inspect educational institutions for complaints of corporal punishment, and to take action following investigations, official proceedings are hardly carried out, as most of the cases are settled through arbitration. And even if a case is dealt with officially, the usual outcome remains limited to just warning the accused teacher.

Finally, what made Alfaj think that a student could die after receiving corporal punishment from him, and that it would be the appropriate time for the student’s guardian to seek an explanation from him? Is there any rule or law that permits a teacher to explain his actions to the parents of a student who died after being punished by him?

Not only were Alfaj’s actions yet another example of the High Court's orders on corporal punishment being violated, but they have also raised questions that demand official proceedings, provided the authorities concerned are eager to learn what actually happened rather than ruling it out as an “isolated” incident.