I was talking to the CEO of a regional bank in Hong Kong a few days back. He was aware of the increasing greater China-Bangladesh trade traffic. In spite of that, he thought Bangladesh’s banking lacked depth – its governance was weak, the level of automation was low, and only plain vanilla products were in use with the least number of structured solutions or retail client offering.
Since the gentleman spent many years with top-notch American banks, I didn’t debate with him. However, I did refer to the increasing numbers of debit and credit card-holders, the dramatic increase in mobile banking, and the increasing number of process centralisation happening in Bangladeshi commercial banks.
The gentleman, having spent many years in Africa and Eastern and Central Europe in senior roles, was very much aware of the mobile banking successes in Kenya, and lately Bangladesh. However, to my utter surprise, he thought mobile banking to be a very good domestic remittance product or transporter, not doing much for financial inclusion.
He was rather appreciative of the microfinance institutions which are bringing visible changes in the lives of the rural people and are helping with the rise of entrepreneurship at the “bottom of the pyramid” – he thought of that to be more about financial inclusion.
I asked him what was keeping him busy. He answered that, apart from allocating too much of his time towards ensuring governance and compliance to regulatory warrants, they were busy with developing structured solutions for large Chinese corporate houses, wealth management products for emerging rich groups in the greater China, and IT-driven transaction banking products.
Bangladeshi banking has come a long way over the last 43 years. However, it is also true that, other than the management of cross-border trade volume increasing, we were unable to do much. Large classified loans, low automation, the least possible number of retail banking solutions, low access to Internet banking, concentration of banking limits, or exposure to few groups or families (that too in cash credit) hypothecation of assets, import loans, and term loans are synonymous of Bangladeshi banking. The lowest possible number of large corporate houses is present in the capital market.
If we consider the booming mobile banking sector, with almost 50 million clients and a Tk10,000 crore turnover per month, we have reasons to rejoice. However, cellphone companies had more to do here than banks.
Yet, it could not do much to create access to wealth or better products for rural folks. Again, the MFIs played a significant role here. 90% of the bank loans go to urban areas, where only 15% of the bank deposits come from rural areas. Banks are apple-polishing a few wealthy or politically influential groups, denting the dreams of anybody who is less than their regulatory boss.
Too many banks and far too few banking solutions or products are also not helping the banks maintain or strengthen their profitability. Banks’ shares are being traded at a sub optimum level, forcing the eyebrows of international investors to raise, making them doubt their ability to make decent returns for the investors.
Continuously weak governance is not helping the regulatory seniors to sleep well. Surprises may appear from any corner any day, with more Hall-Mark or Bismillah syndromes. Lower profitability is not helping the banks to invest much on people-development, process re-engineering, or an upgraded IT delivery platform.
What should we do then? Improve supervisory capacity of watchdog agencies; foster increased interaction and liaise between the central bank, capital market, insurance agencies, the MFI, and revenue board seniors; reduce or stop overzealous board interference in day-to-day bank affairs, and let the independent directors work independently of the sponsors or directors; link bank borrowing with clients’ capital bases, and allow wealth-management products to flourish.
Banks should be seen investing more in information technology, the creation of new educated entrepreneurs through venture capital funding, alternate banking channels, and capital market-linked product development. Time has also come to focus more on insurance-linked products or bank assurance, bio-metric banking, data mining, and backbone process development. Quality should speak, not quantity always.