No major changes abroad

By the time you read this, Republicans would have made significant gains in the American mid-term elections from last Tuesday and, very likely, won the Senate, thus giving them full control of Congress for the last two years of Democrat Barack Obama’s presidency. 

This may signal more polarisation in the domestic policymaking arena in the United States and will likely trigger even more intense battles over the shape of budgets, entitlement reforms, and environmental regulations. But observers abroad need not be too worried about at least one thing.

As far as foreign policy is concerned, not much is going to change in substantive terms despite the frequent criticisms that the Obama administration fields from Republican legislators regarding his handling of foreign affairs.

Constitutional provisions, statutory interpretations, and respected traditions going back at least to the end of the Second World War give the president of the United States a much stronger hand in the implementation and execution of foreign policy vis-à-vis the otherwise powerful Congress.

The broad swath of American policy beyond its borders includes, of course, issues pertaining to national and global security, trade, immigration, and human rights. While changing the tenor and tone to a more lawyerly pitch than his famously swaggering predecessor, President Obama has largely kept in place the broad contours of the Bush foreign policy.

The foreign policy agenda of George W Bush, a man in whose presidential campaign I worked in 2000, pivoted on three hinges: National security and counter-terrorism, trade and immigration, democracy and human rights.

With a nod to an appearance of greater collaboration with allies, President Obama has not only continued the Bush legacy but, in some ways, doubled down on it: Surveillance activity is at an all-time high, American-led coalition forces continue to strike at developing threats, free trade is pushed as the touchstone of global uplift, and tertiary-level advocacy of democracy and human rights continues.

With the Senate in Republican hands, ironically, the president may find it easier to renew his office’s authority to negotiate free trade agreements, an area where a strange combination of labour union supporting Democrats and isolationist, nativist Republicans was able to thwart his desire.

Nonetheless, no such luck is likely forthcoming to the president on the immigration issue: Like his predecessor, he too is destined to see the business-community supported immigration reform measures get stuck in a Congress where, after last Tuesday, the nativist and insular voices will be even louder.

Where one may see some hesitation with the president’s broad foreign policy agenda now, is the Senate exercising more scrutiny of ambassadorial nominees and the full Congress using the power of the budget to push for more muscle behind the rhetoric of democracy and human rights.

The rather lacklustre response of the Obama administration to highly irregular elections in Myanmar, Venezuela, and Bangladesh may, for a change, get a deeper look in the foreign relations committees of the Republican-controlled Congress.

Beyond such sniping at the margins, it is highly unlikely that the Republican legislators can do much to alter even the tone of the Obama foreign policy. For starters, the Republican party’s caucuses in Congress are spectacularly divided between the hawkish, internationalist, and isolationist wings, leaving the party without a coherent alternative to the Obama approach to foreign policy.

Confounding the absence of an alternative narrative is the Senate lineup where the current Republican leadership has no figures of global stature at par with previous Republican Senate leaders like Bob Dole, Howard Baker, and Robert Taft.

Bottom line is that in terms of the proverbial “meat and potatoes” of American foreign policy, there is likely to be very little change as a result of this week’s elections in the United States.