A culture of evidence

For all the consternation about the University of Dhaka – what to say about all the other institutions in the country – not being in the list of the world’s noted 2,000 universities in the Global Shanghai rankings, it comes as little surprise to those who have seen the negative evolution of the culture of knowledge in Bangladesh and elsewhere in the Muslim world. The problem is structural and financial to some extent; but it runs far deeper and much more dangerously so.

One of the less heralded achievements of the twin phenomena of Reformation and Enlightenment was the consolidation of the scientific method as the globe’s gold standard for knowledge creation, validation, and diffusion across a multiple array of disciplines.

Drawing strands from the methodologies of Greeks, Arabs, Persians, and Indians, the philosophers, physicists, historians, and social scientists of that era, gave posterity what is today the only valid criteria for producing, affirming, challenging, and improving knowledge through an iterative process of observations, propositions, hypothesis testing, empirical data, theory construct, replication, and independent professional peer review.

Millions of articles, studies, and reviews in the thousands of professional journals across the world every month testify to the position of the scientific method as the sole criteria for real knowledge creation in the realm of learned men and women. 

Put it another way, in the world of real knowledge, regardless of the subject matter, evidence and independent verification matters while beliefs, anecdotes, hunches, emotions, and hearsay do not. That many people do not understand the difference between evidence and data on one hand, and hearsay and anecdotes on the other, does not make properly discovered knowledge any less valid. 

Just because 3 million people believe that mustard seeds will cure cancer because their neighbour had a relative who had an in-law who had a friend who was rumored to be cured thus, does not mean cancer can be cured by mustard seeds; but if three clinical researchers provide peer reviewed and heretofore unchallenged evidence that cancer can be arrested by chemotherapy, chances are they have some legs to stand on. The sheer number of believers or the raw volume of vocal chords has no relevance to the currency of Truth, as far as the sciences – physical, social, and biological – are concerned. 

This cultural problem has only been exacerbated by the polarisation in politics where the dictum of “if you are not with us, you are the enemy” holds sway stronger than ever before, and debates are often waged on the basis of wild accusations and unalloyed assertions unencumbered by fact.

We have come to a point that even ostensibly educated people look at the world around them informed by nothing more than worn-out conspiracy theories which are, then, used as crutches to explain away all the ills that befall their own fates. Ask yourself honestly: When was the last time you engaged in a dialogue with friends, colleagues, or family when someone did not blame England, America, Jews, Hindus, India, or Pakistan for something? You see, blaming someone who is the “other” is much easier than the discipline it takes to find answers to problems, and humility to admit one’s own shortcomings.

The craft of rational knowledge creation is, by nature, an exercise in humility, for it does not have the luxury of certitude that blind faith or rigid ideology brings. Written oracles, fiery speeches, and quotes gleaned from Facebook memes do not constitute the validation of any argument, notwithstanding the passion or pathos contained therein.

The culture of evidence relies on data analysis rather than (misplaced) historical analogies like the oft-repeated “Oxford of the East” moniker. Granted, such a culture of evidence is not built overnight, but it is unlikely to be built at all without the doyens of education and journalism saying “enough is enough.”

Journalists worth their salt should be challenging demagogues – political or otherwise – to prove fanciful accusations, and conspiracy theories with verifiable evidence, while professors should be expecting their students to back up their statements with fact rather than faith.

Faith and ideology have their place; genuine scholarship is not that place. At least, not in the year 2014.