Bring sexuality out in the open

The other day, during the Eid holidays, I was talking to a budding filmmaker who was expressing his disgust at the hypocrisy of society, pointing to an incident where a well-known TV channel cut off a part of a submitted tele-film where a girl out on a boat ride with friends, casually asks: “What will happen if one of the girls in the group feels the urge to use the toilet?”

The rationale to cut off that part was that such a line cannot come from the mouth of a female because “society” does not expect women to talk freely on certain issues.

Juxtapose this with the recent death by drowning of a teenage school student called Zubair who, as an array of evidence now suggests, was trying to draw the line between friendship and intimacy with his male swimming instructor.

The swimming coach, an Algerian national, was said to have barraged the young boy with relentless messages that cross over from close comradeship into a relationship format, which borders on paedophilia – unarguably the most egregious of crimes.

Just imagine, when a TV channel decides to omit the mentioning of an every-day ritual, fearing to upset the so-called chaste social template that we are supposed to believe in, how can young people, at the most crucial period of their lives, decide on matters that have always been diligently avoided?

This newspaper has printed some of the details of the messages that were exchanged between the foreign national and the boy, bringing to the open the matter of same-sex relations plus the reprehensible exploitation of young minds.

In this case, the boy was asserting his position on friendship through his online messages while the pressure for something more was being created by the Algerian man. Naturally, Zubair did not share this with his family seriously, dismissing the approaches of the man as just a joke.

In fact, several times, his reaction to the foreigner’s blunt approach was lighthearted – an act we now feel was the biggest mistake. Whether the man, who is now in police custody, was responsible for the death or not, once more, we come face-to-face with a situation where rusty notions about adolescent demons clash with an evolved social credo.

The fear to talk openly about same-sex relations stems from deeply entrenched beliefs about what is accepted and what is not, but let’s be frank here – life is not black and white, and existential complications can never be generalised in accordance to one set of inflexible definitions.

Download "Best of 2014"

Hypothetically, if Zubair had not refused the advances of the swimming coach and had reacted favourably, then what would be the reaction of his relatives and friends?

Same-sex relations may not be encouraged, but while we live in a highly changed social setting, it’s time to talk about it openly because otherwise, taking advantage of the self-imposed ignorance, miscommunication, and in certain cases indoctrination, can happen, leading to disastrous consequences.

Since Zubair was a teenager, any talk of a sexual nature with him falls within the category of paedophilia and hence, the foreigner must be deported. Just to go back a few months, there was news of a Bangladeshi filmmaker who had been caught while trying to sell locally made porn involving street children to buyers abroad.

Caution was aired back then that child-porn makers, manipulating our gullibility, may be running a large operation here without having raised any suspicion. With the recent death of a teen and the alleged involvement of a foreigner trying to impose intimacy, that fear comes back.

Now the knee-jerk reaction may be: Deport the Algerian man, be alert of such foreigners trying to get close to young boys, and enforce traditional values.

While as a first step this may be right to many, as an essential second step, parents and guardians must bring up sexuality as a natural topic when children reach puberty.

The discussion needs to be practical, based on the realities of the modern world, and not based on unbending prescriptions which have no link whatsoever with the actual picture.

Even now, our popular culture cannot show a man and a woman enjoying an intimate pre-marital relationship, though a survey of the sale of morning-after pills will give us the true picture. Whether this is right or wrong is relative, because as society moves on with its positives and negatives, trying to forcefully plaster a righteous label will only work to nurture the defects within.

Whether we like it or not, the so-called “rokkhonshil” (conservative) pretense has to be thrown out. While sexual exploitation of young minds needs to be addressed with the required stringency, the shunned topic of sex and its manifestations need to be discussed, not with dogmatism but with practicality.

Like I said earlier, society has never been, and never will, conform to any fixed definition – a liberal mindset is the best way to get along with the times. So, let us begin by thinking that transvestites, gays, and lesbians are not outside the society, they are in it. Just handing out some money to Hijras at the traffic intersection does not end our duty. 

Keeping them at the fringes is not a full-time solution.

As for popular entertainment which is supposed to be the reflection of the ideology of a certain time, please portray society with its flaws and virtues and not try to show that women do not need to use the toilet or never feel the desire of the flesh.