Democracy: The only answer

Some say that democracy is the rule of the stupid; that it considers people as essentially stupid. A bit harsh, in my opinion; unsuspecting, gullible, easily duped, and totally naive about the machinations of running a state seems a more likely assessment. But democracy it has to be.

So what if people only participate on the day of the polls? They select some of their own to represent the whole, the select few are assumed to be smarter and more capable than most to run the day-to-day businesses of the government, enact laws, scrap laws that do not reflect the will of the people, and somehow try to ensure justice to prevail in the state.

Autocracy or totalitarianism will fail in the long run. A monarchy will never ensure the rights of the people, even if the subjects remain subservient to a monarch, the grandeur of the monarchy will, in time, lose lustre and people will be bound to rise up against it.

Some monarchies that are going strong, apparently in the Middle East, will ultimately fail if they do not go for an inclusive method of governance. The Caliphate professed by the Islamic State will never be able to sustain itself. It is anachronistic, brutal, and will never empower people.

Communism also will never succeed. If history has taught us anything, we do not want to share everything we have with the people next door. Avarice is an inherently human quality.

We may want some sort of social justice, but giving up a higher position in life for the sake of standing shoulder-to-shoulder with someone who is presumed to be weaker? No way. The failure of communism has nothing to do with banning religion, it is because we are human, and we are imperfect.

Now, democracy as we see is not flawless. A select few still end up cornering power but they can always be voted out, and then a new group is voted in and given the reins until they are wrested from them when the people do not approve anymore.

The problem with democracy is the ever-increasing level of hypocrisy. The head of a state is always going for photo-ops, taking a child from the crowd and trying to put up an angelic image of himself/herself, going to disaster affected areas and faking concern, shedding a tear or two as an obituary to the recently demised political opponent, etcetra etcetra etcetra.

Democratic regimes often resort to various forms of nepotism, some more than others, hence the terms oligarchy, oligopoly, plutocracy, and such.

The problem with hypocrisy becomes stark when people see the lawmakers themselves breaking the law at will, and persecuting someone holding a view contrary to theirs, all the time screaming about freedom of speech and choice. The demagogues scream for the wrong so loud that people start to doubt what they have always believed to be right.

Those with contrary views who are screaming for the right reasons are shoved violently or surreptitiously into a “dark closet,” and the ones holding power bang their drums so loudly to the general masses that the right is actually made to appear as wrong.

With control over the media and use of spin doctors they almost always succeed, but not all the time. A democratic society somehow or other brings a voice of contradiction to the fore and that voice rocks the citadel.

Problems with democracy are seen all over the world, in both the developed as well as the developing countries. However, in a developed country, opposition cannot be stifled as easily, and that is one of the reasons that they have become developed. An active and vibrant opposition will always keep the group in power within a sphere of accountability even if both groups consist of hypocrites and political power players.

Amidst all these problems, democracy takes a country forward and some level of equity is established. Some countries are better off than others; the Nordic countries are at the top of the tree while the wealthiest democracy, the United States, is lagging in several sectors.

In spite of a poor political culture, Bangladesh has forged ahead under democratic governments, all the years spent under martial law only deferred the level of development that her people have shown could be achieved.

If military dictators, with all the unnecessary defense spending and policies aimed at staying in power, had not been ruling this country for almost 17 of her 43 years, Bangladesh would most probably have been a middle income country by now.

We have no choice but to nurture democracy and show political maturity and somehow bring about a better political culture where power holders and the groups outside of power will always put the country first and their debates will only empower people more.

None of their programs will disrupt the lives of the masses or impede the progress of the country. This will force the scourge of our country, ie corruption, to be reined in, and the yawning difference between the very rich and very poor to narrow down appreciably.