No silver spoon

The year is 2014. No shortage of socialites, social workers, and community service club volunteers clamouring for photo-ops with smiling children in low-income classrooms. There is a genuine willingness to finance new schools in high need areas and enrol more students into them. And post photos on Facebook. That is where the train to progress stops.

Why aren’t more people I know equally invested in the biggest issue crippling our education sector: The disparity in quality of education that seals the fate of students at birth?

Most educated people, including perhaps even you, inadvertently carry within them two different ideas about education, a double standard that they rarely recognise because they don’t often have an opportunity to reflect upon it.

For themselves, many imagine an education that will translate into university, jobs, and social status.

When talking about education for the masses, however, many inadvertently envision basic literacy. They think of an orderly society where the masses follow traffic laws and where migrant labourers behave appropriately in airplanes. In this utopian society, they are still the elites, that is to say, most people do not envision education as a means of upward mobility in realistic terms for children in low income communities.

They don’t envision freethinkers and leaders coming out of slum schools. Instead, as the cliches go, they are prone to guarding their advantages in life, hoping that a subpar education will suffice for children who make up a significant chunk of our population.

Accordingly, the same people don’t see the need to bring the quality of education in low-income communities at par with the country’s leading institutions. This hypocrisy, while often subconscious, is still palpable in their anxious resistance to improving the quality of education at the nation’s worst schools.

To put things bluntly, such transformations would ultimately lead to upheavals we try not to think about in a rigidly stratified society. Not convinced? Here is a hypothetical (admittedly simplistic) exercise: Imagine your former housemaid brings her son, who having had access to competitive education, is now a surgeon at the best hospital in the city. How will you receive mother and son? Where will you ask them to sit – in your drawing room where you entertain your esteemed guests or whatever space you set aside for your subordinates?

If this sounds like a difficult question to answer, that’s because it is. Or rather it’s daunting because that’s what our society makes it out to be. Perhaps the answers are simple.

When we talk about improving the quality of education across the nation, we also mean a redistribution of many of the privileges that have so far been dictated by class and birth. We mean opening up opportunities that were once reserved for us alone. We mean that our children will have fewer unchecked advantages in life than we did, they will have to compete for the jobs they might have once been handed on a silver platter.

We mean a change in status quo, a process which may (or may not) reduce our power and control because an education, an ideal one, gives individuals the capacity to think for themselves and an educated population may justifiably decide against selfish interests. It means uncertainty for our future generations. And we are asking ourselves to willingly sign up for this agenda by improving schools and teachers everywhere.

These are the real fears I see on people’s faces when they defend their position or rationalise against education equity – I can see them clearly because I have felt them inside me too. How can you not, growing up here?

Losing your few advantages in life is not meant to be an easy exercise. If it doesn’t make you flinch, you have reached an admirable Zen state. If you want to keep a lock on your class privileges, so be it. At least you might admit that to yourself.

For the rest of us, the issue of education equality should be an open and constant conversation where we can explore our assumptions, inner conflicts, motivations, and ideas for the future. What kind of a society should we try to build? Are we willing to truly make our privileges obsolete and strive to provide equal opportunity for all? Difficulties notwithstanding, that might just be the most rational choice.