Since the Durga Puja celebrations began a few days ago, two photographs have been making rounds on my social media: One shows a girl in a hijab, presumably standing on her toes, excitedly trying to ring the bell at a temple.
The other one shows a little boy in his Islamic attire (tupi and panjabi), standing in front of a temple, absorbed in the puja celebrations.
I’ve seen a lot of friends share these photos, excited at the sense of religious harmony that these photos apparently represent -- Muslim boy in Hindu temple, Hijabi girl ringing the bell during a puja.
How much better could it possibly get, especially at a time when the nation is fumbling to re-establish its secular identity in the face of rising religious extremism?
But there’s a problematic truth that is ignored when we brand these photos as a representation of “communal harmony” -- and ignoring how it further perpetuates our loosening grip over the secular values the country was founded on.
Every time I came across these photos, a question kept coming back to me: Would it be equally easy for people from other religions to be present inside a mosque during Eid celebrations?
Before we go on celebrating ‘religious harmony,’ we need to change the lens with which we view the issue in our country. Because these photos don’t represent religious harmony -- they represent a mere privilege one religious community enjoys by virtue of being the majority in the country
Doesn’t religious harmony mean an equal access of non-Muslims into mosques as Muslims have to other religious spaces -- in this case, a Hindu temple?
Don’t get me wrong, I believe in religious and communal harmony as any other secular Bangladeshi does. I have nothing against either of these people being in the temples during puja.
I myself celebrate puja with as much excitement as I celebrate Eid -- it is, after all, one of the most festive times of the year. Neither am I suggesting that the Hindu families don’t celebrate Eid with their Muslim friends and neighbours.
But it wasn’t until I saw these photos being shared in spirit of “communal harmony” that I realised how one-sided the lens with which we view this “harmony” is.
These photographs show, at best, the granted access Muslims, the mainstream population in the country, have to the holy place and home of the minority religions.
But since we’re talking about religious harmony, how often do we welcome a woman with a sindoor or a purohit into a mosque? How often have you seen a non-Muslim being welcomed as open-heartedly into a mosque during Eid?
The only thing these photos prove, other than the undeniable hospitality of our Hindu brothers, is the entitled access Muslims enjoy in the holy spaces of other religions that are, at the same time, denied access into the holy space of Muslims in Bangladesh.
That is the exact opposite of religious harmony.
So, before we go on celebrating “religious harmony,” we need to change the lens with which we view the issue in our country. Because these photos don’t represent religious harmony -- they represent a mere privilege one religious community enjoys by virtue of being the majority in the country.
Samira Sadeque is a writer and journalist. You can follow her on Twitter @Samideque.